Best Movers Near New Castle, IN (2025 Guide)

Ryan Carrigan

Last Updated: Dec 2, 2025 • 5 min read

Fact Checked by: Hilary Snow

Our research of 60 movers across Indiana revealed that Two Guys And A Truck is the best option for local moves in New Castle, IN. Their 151 reviews show a company with a strong customer track record — 78.8% of them are positive.

Those planning a move out of state will find Safeway Moving to be a reliable and affordable choice.

Hi, I'm Ryan.
Let's get moving.

I've helped thousands of people move over the last decade, and I can tell you that no two moves are exactly alike. Let me help you find the mover that's right for you.

Best local IN mover:

Two Guys And A Truck

4.52
Best interstate mover:

Safeway Moving

4.85
Best DIY moving option:

U-Haul Truck Rental

4.15

Need more help? Build your move plan.

Get Quote

Preferred partners

Company	Quote	Rating
Safeway Moving	Get A Quote	4.85 / 5
International Van Lines	Get A Quote	4.45 / 5
Mayzlin Relocation	Get A Quote	4.9 / 5

Our track record

Each year, 400,000+ people trust our moving recommendations. Here are a few reasons why:

Founded in 2015
3,500+ moving companies analyzed
$50,000 in moving grants delivered
Up-to-date pricing info & industry data
Fact-checked for accuracy

5 Cheapest movers when moving locally in New Castle, IN

Whether you're planning a move within New Castle or relocating to a nearby Indiana city like Mount Summit or Greensboro (both under 50 miles away), we’ve rounded up some of the best local movers that combine solid reputations with affordable pricing.

Two Guys And A Truck: 4.52 out of 5 stars
Leaders Moving & Storage Co.: 4.64 out of 5 stars
Planes Moving & Storage Company: 4.58 out of 5 stars
TWO MEN AND A TRUCK: 4.5 out of 5 stars
Bellhop Moving: 4.58 out of 5 stars

Two Guys And A Truck

5702 Dr Martin Luther King Jr Blvd, Anderson, IN 46013 US

79% of all reviews were positive

18% of reviews were negative

Read Reviews

Review Analysis

Moving with Two Guys And A Truck means enjoying a prompt, efficient process guided by polite professionals. Out of 151 customer feedback comments, nearly 79% praised the company’s slick coordination, reliable workers, careful handling, and honest pricing. Many customers cite speedy moves, no hidden costs, and a reassuring attention to fragile items. Staff politeness and work ethic stand out, with many reviewers saying teams were friendly and quick to respond. On the other hand, about 18% of the input highlights issues: broken or mishandled items, surprise charges, and difficulty securing updates after damage or claims. Only a handful found fault with communication or costs, while neutral feedback points to inconsistent office coordination or minor mistakes. Reviews confirm that Two Guys And A Truck meets or often surpasses industry standards for professionalism and efficiency, though those with large or complex moves should double-check details and communicate expectations clearly to avoid dissatisfaction.

Get a Quote (317) 776-1447

Company Info

Years in Business: 31

DOT #: 1055325

Alternate Names: John Mitchell Moving - Two Guys and a Truck, Inc.

Services Offered

Local moves
Interstate moves
Packing
Unpacking
Offices
Pianos
Pool Tables
Art
Antiques
Crating
Full-valuation coverage
Storage
Pay by cash
Pay by credit card

Leaders Moving & Storage Co.

9900 Westpoint Drive, Indianapolis, IN 46256 US

89% of all reviews were positive

10% of reviews were negative

Read Reviews

Review Analysis

Moving with Leaders Moving & Storage Co. means working with a crew known for professionalism, efficiency, and careful handling. Of the 248 customer responses analyzed, 89% gave positive feedback, consistently highlighting friendly staff, speedy and careful work, and helpful attitudes. Many praised the team’s ability to handle heavy or delicate items and transparency with pricing. Customers valued clear communication, organized crews, and prompt service, noting that many movers went the extra mile to ease their stress. On the other hand, roughly 10% of responses described issues such as items being damaged, inexperienced team members, and breakdowns in communication, with a few citing frustrating claims processes. A small number of customers felt that their movers lacked preparation or that management did not resolve complaints to their satisfaction. Compared to other companies in the moving industry, Leaders stands out for how often its staff receive recognition for both their skill and respectful, helpful approach. Most clients reported moves that finished on time, with their belongings arriving safely and all expectations met or exceeded.

Get a Quote (317) 280-3385

Company Info

Years in Business: 30

DOT #: 1237577

Alternate Names: L.E.A.D.E.R.S Moving & Storage Co., Leaders Moving and Storage Company, Hilling Moving & Storage

Services Offered

Local moves
Interstate moves
Packing
Unpacking
Offices
Crating
Storage
Pay by credit card

Planes Moving & Storage Company

2635 Planes Dr, Indianapolis, IN 46219 US

89% of all reviews were positive

10% of reviews were negative

Read Reviews

Review Analysis

Planes Moving & Storage earns praise for its professional, helpful staff and efficient moving process, backed by 236 reviews with nearly 90% positive feedback. Customers often highlight careful handling of items, prompt service, and friendly movers who make the relocation much easier than with other companies. Many clients say the teams take extra steps to protect property and communicate well throughout moves. Affordability and transparent pricing also surface as advantages. In contrast, the most common complaints involve significant damage to belongings, unresolved compensation issues, and lack of communication from coordinators. Some people report surprise charges or poor response to claims. The volume and consistency of positive input position Planes ahead of most moving companies in reliability and customer satisfaction, though a few negative cases stand out for property damage and service gaps.

Get a Quote (317) 895-1444

Company Info

Years in Business: 105

DOT #: 1458935

Alternate Names: Planes Companies, Planes Specialized Logistics, Planes Commercial Services

Services Offered

Local moves
Interstate moves
International moves
Packing
Unpacking
Offices
Pianos
Pool Tables
Art
Antiques
Crating
Shipment tracking
Storage
Pay by credit card

TWO MEN AND A TRUCK

11787 Technology Drive, Fishers, IN 46038 US

74% of all reviews were positive

25% of reviews were negative

Read Reviews

Review Analysis

Moving day becomes less stressful with Two Men and a Truck, as most customer feedback highlights fast, careful service and professional, friendly movers. Out of 275 reviews, more than 73% share positive experiences where belongings arrived undamaged and staff communicated well. Customers often mention efficient moves, polite crews, and attention to detail. On the other hand, nearly one in four reviews reports issues. The most common complaints are item damage, unexpected extra charges, and poor follow-up or unreturned calls. Some customers also describe claim handling as frustrating and communication inconsistent. Compared to many movers, Two Men and a Truck earns strong marks for reliability and care, but can fall short if problems occur or billing lacks clarity. The majority recommend the service, especially for those wanting speed and careful handling, but caution to stay vigilant about billing and follow-up after the move.

Get a Quote (317) 412-9461

Company Info

Years in Business: 19

DOT #: 2527384

Alternate Names: Solutum Moving & Storage, Inc.

Services Offered

Local moves
Interstate moves
Packing
Unpacking
Pianos
Storage
Safes
Pay by credit card

Bellhop Moving

4916 Lemans Drive, Indianapolis, IN 46205 US

70% of all reviews were positive

26% of reviews were negative

Read Reviews

Review Analysis

Customers rave about Bellhop Moving’s speed, efficiency, and friendly approach. Out of 115 reviews, nearly 70% share positive input, highlighting fast-moving crews, affordable prices, clear communication, and respectful service. Many describe the process as easy and stress-free. On the downside, about a quarter of feedback points to problems like late arrivals, damaged belongings, and a lack of follow-through from customer service. Complaints focus on delayed service, unwrapped or mishandled items, and poor responsiveness when issues arise. Compared to traditional movers, Bellhop often wins on price and flexibility but loses ground on reliability during peak times. Most customers praise the courteous staff and quick booking, yet a minority experienced significant disruptions or property damage. While Bellhop is often a cost-effective and efficient choice, those with high-value or complex moves may want to weigh the risk of potential delays or mishandling before booking.

Get a Quote (866) 774-5063

Company Info

State license #: 2878240

Years in Business: 13

DOT #: 2878240

Alternate Names: Bellhops, Inc.

Services Offered

Local moves
Interstate moves
Packing
Unpacking
Storage
Pay by credit card
Deposit Required

Local moving services in New Castle

Location plays a big role in what moving services you’ll have access to, since some areas have more specialty options than others.

We’ve broken down how many movers in New Castle, IN, offer specific services and compared that to availability across the state and the country so you have a better sense of what’s easy to find and what might be harder to come by where you live.

Service	New Castle	IN	National
Packing	12	55	3074
Unpacking	12	54	2974
Packing Materials	5	25	1814
Piano	9	43	2300
Antiques	5	21	1465
Debris Removal	4	16	821
Art	3	16	1449
Storage	10	48	2696
Climate-Controlled Storage	6	25	1035
Small Moves	5	30	1555
Fragile-Only Packing	2	13	748
Custom Crating	10	35	1929
Hot Tub	1	5	692
Junk Removal	6	30	1153
Office Moves	11	47	2710
Pool Table	3	14	969
Safe	2	19	1155

Other local IN movers

While these local Indiana movers did not make our top list, they are still worth looking into:

Top-rated movers in other nearby Indiana cities

If you need something local New Castle movers don’t offer, consider checking out other trusted companies in IN cities. You might find a better fit just a short drive away.

See less

Cheapest movers when moving out of Indiana

Making a move from Indiana to another state? You'll want a reliable interstate moving company to handle the journey. Check out our top picks

Safeway Moving: 4.85 out of 5 stars
International Van Lines: 4.45 out of 5 stars
Mayzlin Relocation: 4.9 out of 5 stars
PODS: 4.8 out of 5 stars
American Van Lines: 4.5 out of 5 stars

Safeway Moving

rating

4.85 / 5

Licensed

Insured

Price

Best overall value
Portion to charity
Veteran owned

Get A Quote

(855) 650-0657

International Van Lines

rating

4.45 / 5

Licensed

Insured

Price

24/7 cust. service
Competitive rates
10% discounts

Get A Quote

(855) 929-4120

Mayzlin Relocation

rating

4.9 / 5

Licensed

Insured

Price

Family owned
East coast focus
Affordable pricing

Get A Quote

(980) 217-6841

PODS

rating

4.8 / 5

Licensed

Insured

Price

Unlimited storage
3 container sizes
10% discount

Get A Quote

Visit Website

American Van Lines

rating

4.5 / 5

Licensed

Insured

Price

Certified crews
Flat-rate pricing
Family-owned

Get A Quote

866-835-2392

Cheapest DIY moving options in New Castle, IN

A full-service mover can make your New Castle, Indiana relocation stress-free, but it often comes with a higher price tag. To save a bit, you might want to look into the best moving container companies or explore rental truck options available in New Castle.

PODS

rating

4.8 / 5

Licensed

Insured

Price

Unlimited storage
3 container sizes
10% discount

Get A Quote

Visit Website

U-Pack

rating

5 / 5

Licensed

Insured

Price

Fast delivery
Nationwide
100+ miles moves

Check prices Visit Website

MovingYourself

rating

4.5 / 5

Licensed

Insured

Price

Affordable pricing
Offers car shipping
No hidden fees

Get A Quote

(352) 322-2920

Budget Truck Rental

rating

4.3 / 5

Licensed

Insured

Price

Affordable pricing
Online pricing
Several discounts

Check prices Visit Website

Skip the strain without skipping the savings. If you’re planning a DIY move in New Castle, you’ve got 5 labor-only services to choose from — a great solution for getting help when you need it most.

How we chose the best movers in New Castle, IN

moveBuddha’s expert team analyzed moving rates from 41 Indiana movers and listed the top five best movers based on customer satisfaction, reviews, and cost.

Customer satisfaction (40%): The company consistently delivers services in a timely matter with good communication and within the estimated cost.

Dispute resolution (20%): Mistakes cannot be avoided in the moving industry. We look for companies that own their mistakes and make genuine efforts to fix any issues that arise during a move.

Industry reputation (15%): The company is well-regarded within the moving industry and participates in industry conferences and organizations.

Online reputation (15%): The company maintains a professional website with accurate information. The company promptly and professionally responds to online customer inquiries.

Service options (10%): We look for companies with a deep breadth of services including full packing, storage, specialty item handling, and expedited delivery.

Here is our full moving company rating methodology.

Average cost of movers in New Castle, IN

The pricing table below offers a general sense of what you might pay for a local move in the New Castle area. To learn more, take a look at our full guide to moving costs in Indiana.

The moving quotes listed are ballpark figures—your final cost could be higher or lower depending on your individual move. For a more tailored estimate, use our moving cost calculator.

Home Size	Avg. Total Cost	Cost/hour	# of Movers	# Hours
Studio	$321	$100	2 movers	3 hours
1 Bedroom	$421	$100	2 movers	4 hours
2 Bedroom	$640	$140	3 movers	5 hours
3 Bedroom	$1,395	$196	4 movers	8 hours
4 Bedroom	$1,591	$196	4 movers	9 hours
5+ Bedroom	$2,410	$274	5 movers	10 hours

Compare the top New Castle, IN movers

Let’s compare how the top movers in New Castle, IN stack up in terms of their reputation.

Company	moveBuddha rating	BBB rating	Yelp rating	Google rating
Two Guys And A Truck	4.5/5	A+	3.7/5	4.2/5
Leaders Moving & Storage Co.	4.6/5	A+	2.8/5	4.8/5
Planes Moving & Storage Company	4.6/5	A+	2.2/5	4.9/5
TWO MEN AND A TRUCK	4.5/5	A+	2.6/5	4.4/5
Bellhop Moving	4.6/5	C	3.6/5	4.4/5
Jones Movers	4.4/5	A+	2.3/5	4.8/5
College Hunks Hauling Junk & Moving	4.4/5	F	3.5/5	4.7/5
Wheaton Moving & Storage	4.4/5	A+	1.9/5	4.2/5
Busy Bee Movers	4.6/5	A+	2.3/5	4.1/5
Soft Touch Moving & Moving	4.4/5	A+	4.7/5	5/5

FAQs

How many movers in New Castle offer discounts?

Most movers provide some type of ongoing discount or seasonal deal. 1 offer military discounts. 1 offer senior citizen discounts.

Promotions can vary company to company and throughout the year, so be sure to ask a potential mover for a full list of discounts, as well as details and restrictions for each type.

How can I tell if a moving company is licensed?

The Indiana Department of Transportation (INDOT) regulate movers operating within Indiana and issue moving companies Indiana Households Goods Carriers Numbers. Check to make sure prospective movers have one and that it’s up to date.

All movers included in our listings hold the proper licenses. Visit our best movers in Indiana roundup for suggestions.

How do I find a reputable New Castle mover?

Looking for a reliable New Castle moving company can be difficult, but there are certain things to consider to ensure you choose a trustworthy mover. These include:

Reputation: A mover's reputation is crucial, whether they're a new mom-and-pop business or a seasoned van lines company.
Dispute resolution: It's best to avoid movers with lots of unresolved customer complaints. Every New Castle moving company will face customer issues. The best companies resolve customer disputes in a timely manner.
Relevant experience: Even if a mover has great reviews for local moves, they may not have the experience needed to handle a cross-country move. Check if they have experience with the type of move you require.

Are there movers in New Castle that go beyond the local area?

Yes. 11 companies in New Castle handle long-distance and interstate moves, in addition to local service. Start with our guide to long-distance movers in New Castle to find the right fit for your relocation needs.

What day is usually the least expensive to move in New Castle, IN?

The most budget-friendly days to hire movers in New Castle, Indiana, are weekdays, since demand tends to be higher on weekends. Generally, the least expensive time to move is during the off-season from October to April. Expect higher rates from May through September due to peak demand.

Booking early is key if you’re planning a move from New Castle. For the best deal, steer clear of weekends, holidays, and the busy summer months. Be cautious with quotes that seem too low—some movers may hike the price significantly on moving day.

What’s the most cost-effective way to move from New Castle, IN to another state?

Renting a truck is typically the cheapest option for moving out of state or around New Castle, Indiana. Just keep in mind that it's a no-frills option. You’ll need to take care of all the packing, loading, unloading, and driving yourself.

Should I consider a moving container for my move from New Castle?

Moving containers are a convenient option if you prefer a flexible schedule. Just be ready to handle the loading and unloading yourself. Once you're packed up, the company picks up the container and delivers it to your new place — no need to worry about driving.

Can I get storage from New Castle moving companies?

10 New Castle movers offer both short- and long-term storage options, and 6 provide climate-controlled units for extra safety of your belongings.

Some companies may rely on third-party storage facilities, so be sure to ask how and where your belongings will be stored. It’s a good idea to confirm availability and costs when comparing movers.

Learn more: Should you use your mover's storage solutions?