Best Movers Near Whitefish Bay, WI (2025 Guide)

Ryan Carrigan

Last Updated: Nov 25, 2025 • 5 min read

Fact Checked by: Hilary Snow

With 39 movers analyzed across Wisconsin, one company stood out in Whitefish Bay, WI. Eagle Moving & Storage Co has earned the top spot locally, backed by 156 online reviews and a strong 76.3% positive rating.

For longer hauls beyond state borders, Safeway Moving is our top pick. They offer high-quality service with pricing that remains budget-friendly.

Hi, I'm Ryan.
Let's get moving.

I've helped thousands of people move over the last decade, and I can tell you that no two moves are exactly alike. Let me help you find the mover that's right for you.

Best local WI mover:

Eagle Moving & Storage Co

4.48
Best interstate mover:

Safeway Moving

4.85
Best DIY moving option:

U-Haul Truck Rental

4.15

Need more help? Build your move plan.

Get Quote

Preferred partners

Company	Quote	Rating
Safeway Moving	Get A Quote	4.85 / 5
International Van Lines	Get A Quote	4.45 / 5
Mayzlin Relocation	Get A Quote	4.9 / 5

Our track record

Each year, 400,000+ people trust our moving recommendations. Here are a few reasons why:

Founded in 2015
3,500+ moving companies analyzed
$50,000 in moving grants delivered
Up-to-date pricing info & industry data
Fact-checked for accuracy

5 Cheapest movers when moving locally in Whitefish Bay, WI

If you are moving within Whitefish Bay — or to a nearby Wisconsin city like Shorewood or Glendale that is 50 miles or less from Whitefish Bay — check out these affordable, top-rated moving companies:

Eagle Moving & Storage Co: 4.48 out of 5 stars
Schroeder Moving Systems Inc.: 4.44 out of 5 stars
TWO MEN AND A TRUCK: 4.36 out of 5 stars
Hernia Movers Inc: 4.26 out of 5 stars
Brothers Moving & Storage: 4.34 out of 5 stars

Eagle Moving & Storage Co

929 West Bruce Street, Milwaukee, WI 53204 US

76% of all reviews were positive

22% of reviews were negative

Read Reviews

Review Analysis

Top-rated service stands out at Eagle Moving & Storage Co, with 76% of feedback sharing satisfaction and frequent praise for the team's professionalism, polite attitude, and prompt handling of belongings. Customers report efficient, quick moves, careful treatment of items, and transparent prices, even during complex or large moves. Repeat clients and referrals underline a dependable experience—an advantage compared to moving companies with inconsistent performance. On the critical side, problems include item damage, lost possessions, and some delays, and a few customers describe customer service as unresponsive during claims or after property issues. Most feedback shows Eagle sets a higher bar for reliability, though occasional mistakes in handling or communication may occur.

Get a Quote (414) 383-1776

Company Info

Years in Business: 94

DOT #: 689374

Services Offered

Local moves
Interstate moves
Packing
Unpacking
Offices
Pianos
Storage
Pay by credit card

Schroeder Moving Systems Inc.

15700 W Lincoln, New Berlin, WI 53151 US

75% of all reviews were positive

21% of reviews were negative

Read Reviews

Review Analysis

Moving with Schroeder Moving Systems Inc. means reliable service and a professional team. Analyzing 92 pieces of feedback, about 75% rated their move positively. Customers mention the movers’ polite approach, careful treatment of belongings, and smooth, consistent communication. Many praised efficient handling and said they would highly recommend Schroeder to friends and family. Some noted fast, stress-free service and clear organization throughout the process. On the other hand, negative input points to issues such as items damaged during moves, sudden extra charges, and rare cases of misplaced property. Delayed or mishandled claims and confusing reimbursement for damage reported by a few set Schroeder apart from the top tier of national movers. Still, their strong rate of satisfied customers stands out compared to many moving companies.

Get a Quote (262) 784-1717

Company Info

Years in Business: 78

DOT #: 514341

Alternate Names: Schroeder Moving Systems of Milwaukee

Services Offered

Local moves
Interstate moves
Packing
Unpacking
Offices
Pianos
Hot Tubs
Pool Tables
Art
Antiques
Crating
Shipment tracking
Full-valuation coverage
Storage
Fragile-only packing
Pay by credit card

TWO MEN AND A TRUCK

11800 West Burleigh Street, Wauwatosa, WI 53222 US

66% of all reviews were positive

33% of reviews were negative

Read Reviews

Review Analysis

Moving experiences with TWO MEN AND A TRUCK stand out for efficient service and staff who are polite, professional, and careful with belongings. Over 65% of 302 customer feedback entries rated their experiences positively, noting quick moves and helpful teams. Customers highlight the movers' attention to detail and their ability to handle complex or heavy items without incident. Despite these strengths, some customers report substantial problems. About 33% of feedback reflects concerns over items damaged during moves, delayed arrivals, or long wait times for claim resolution. Pricing transparency gets mixed input, and a number of users mention issues with complaint handling or lack of follow-up from office staff. Compared to other moving companies, commentary shows that customers regularly return for repeat service, indicating reliability in execution, but some find communication and claims processes less responsive than industry peers. For those valuing speed and courtesy in a move, this company delivers, but vigilance is advised to ensure property protection and prompt service responses.

Get a Quote (414) 220-0994

Company Info

State license #: 877973

Years in Business: 32

DOT #: 2527384

Services Offered

Local moves
Interstate moves
Packing
Unpacking
Pianos
Storage
Safes
Pay by credit card

Hernia Movers Inc

3210 North Pierce Street, Milwaukee, WI 53212 US

84% of all reviews were positive

14% of reviews were negative

Read Reviews

Review Analysis

Moving stress melts away with Hernia Movers, as 204 customer accounts reveal remarkable speed, efficiency, and courtesy. 84% of input praised the swift, professional service, with feedback often highlighting how efficiently teams tackled moves, handled possessions carefully, and maintained polite, helpful attitudes. Customers appreciated clear communication and often noted cost estimates matched the final bill, a rarity among comparable companies. Negative input (14%) focused on damaged items, delayed arrivals, or weak communication—especially regarding repairs or lateness. These issues, though less frequent, sometimes led to frustration about inadequate resolution. A mere 2% of feedback was neutral, often mentioning hiccups with scheduling or truck size, but noting pleasant staff. Compared to other movers, Hernia stands out for reliability, hustle, and consistent professionalism, though the occasional mishap suggests vigilance when valuables are involved.

Get a Quote (414) 263-6402

Company Info

Years in Business: 49

DOT #: 246074

Services Offered

Local moves
Offices
Storage
Pay by credit card

Brothers Moving & Storage

4396 S Kansas Ave, Saint Francis, WI 53235 US

67% of all reviews were positive

32% of reviews were negative

Read Reviews

Review Analysis

When it comes to making a move easier, Brothers Moving & Storage stands out for their friendly, professional movers who consistently demonstrate care with customers' belongings. Of the 73 reviews examined, 67% reflected positive feedback. People mention polite staff, efficient service, and quick, careful moving, while many note helpful attitudes throughout the process. Fast turnaround and respectful handling of property often appear in comments, setting this mover above typical expectations. Still, some customers report damaged items, unexpected charges, and communication gaps—issues that should not be overlooked. The most frequent complaint involves damage to goods, with several citing lost or broken property. Unanticipated fees and slow or unresponsive follow-up are other sources of disappointment. While most clients are glad to recommend Brothers, the negative feedback makes clear that outcomes may differ, especially regarding item safety and billing accuracy. This company receives praise for its work ethic and professionalism but falls short for some when it comes to handling delicate possessions and transparent costs.

Get a Quote (414) 815-6683

Company Info

Years in Business: 12

DOT #: 2301274

Services Offered

Local moves
Packing
Unpacking
Offices
Crating
Storage
Pay by cash
Pay by credit card

Local moving services in Whitefish Bay

Whether or not a moving company offers certain services can depend heavily on the market. What’s common in one place might be nearly impossible to find in another.

This comparison highlights how many movers in Whitefish Bay, WI, offer key services — side-by-side with state and national figures — so you can spot any gaps or standout strengths in your area.

Service	Whitefish Bay	WI	National
Packing	10	36	3068
Unpacking	10	35	2968
Packing Materials	5	16	1808
Piano	5	25	2298
Antiques	2	13	1464
Debris Removal	8	16	819
Art	2	13	1448
Storage	11	28	2691
Climate-Controlled Storage	4	15	1030
Small Moves	6	15	1549
Fragile-Only Packing	2	9	747
Custom Crating	3	17	1928
Hot Tub	1	6	691
Junk Removal	8	22	1151
Office Moves	8	29	2704
Pool Table	1	10	968
Safe	2	11	1155

Other local WI movers

While these local Wisconsin movers did not make our top list, they are still worth looking into:

Top-rated movers in other nearby Wisconsin cities

If you need something local Whitefish Bay movers don’t offer, consider checking out other trusted companies in WI cities. You might find a better fit just a short drive away.

See less

Cheapest movers when moving out of Wisconsin

If you're relocating from Wisconsin to a new state, choosing a trusted interstate moving company is key to making the transition smooth. Here are a few of our top picks to get you started:

Safeway Moving: 4.85 out of 5 stars
International Van Lines: 4.45 out of 5 stars
Mayzlin Relocation: 4.9 out of 5 stars
PODS: 4.8 out of 5 stars
American Van Lines: 4.5 out of 5 stars

Safeway Moving

rating

4.85 / 5

Licensed

Insured

Price

Best overall value
Portion to charity
Veteran owned

Get A Quote

(855) 650-0657

International Van Lines

rating

4.45 / 5

Licensed

Insured

Price

24/7 cust. service
Competitive rates
10% discounts

Get A Quote

(855) 929-4120

Mayzlin Relocation

rating

4.9 / 5

Licensed

Insured

Price

Family owned
East coast focus
Affordable pricing

Get A Quote

(980) 217-6841

PODS

rating

4.8 / 5

Licensed

Insured

Price

Unlimited storage
3 container sizes
10% discount

Get A Quote

Visit Website

American Van Lines

rating

4.5 / 5

Licensed

Insured

Price

Certified crews
Flat-rate pricing
Family-owned

Get A Quote

866-835-2392

Cheapest DIY moving options in Whitefish Bay, WI

While a full-service mover is the most convenient option for your Whitefish Bay, Wisconsin relocation, it will also likely be the most expensive route. To save some money, you may want to consider using one of the top moving container companies, or moving truck rental companies in Whitefish Bay instead.

PODS

rating

4.8 / 5

Licensed

Insured

Price

Unlimited storage
3 container sizes
10% discount

Get A Quote

Visit Website

U-Pack

rating

5 / 5

Licensed

Insured

Price

Fast delivery
Nationwide
100+ miles moves

Check prices Visit Website

MovingYourself

rating

4.5 / 5

Licensed

Insured

Price

Affordable pricing
Offers car shipping
No hidden fees

Get A Quote

(352) 322-2920

Budget Truck Rental

rating

4.3 / 5

Licensed

Insured

Price

Affordable pricing
Online pricing
Several discounts

Check prices Visit Website

Hire help, hold the truck. Not all moving help includes a truck, and that’s good news if you’re renting your own or using a moving container. In Whitefish Bay, 8 labor-only movers can assist with the loading and unloading side of your move.

How we chose the best movers in Whitefish Bay, WI

moveBuddha’s expert team analyzed moving rates from 29 Wisconsin movers and listed the top five best movers based on customer satisfaction, reviews, and cost.

Customer satisfaction (40%): The company consistently delivers services in a timely matter with good communication and within the estimated cost.

Dispute resolution (20%): Mistakes cannot be avoided in the moving industry. We look for companies that own their mistakes and make genuine efforts to fix any issues that arise during a move.

Industry reputation (15%): The company is well-regarded within the moving industry and participates in industry conferences and organizations.

Online reputation (15%): The company maintains a professional website with accurate information. The company promptly and professionally responds to online customer inquiries.

Service options (10%): We look for companies with a deep breadth of services including full packing, storage, specialty item handling, and expedited delivery.

Here is our full moving company rating methodology.

Average cost of movers in Whitefish Bay, WI

Check out the pricing table below to get a rough idea of what local moves typically cost in and around the Whitefish Bay area. For a deeper dive, be sure to explore our guide on the moving costs in Wisconsin.

Keep in mind that the moving quotes shown are general estimates. Your actual expenses may vary based on your specific moving situation. For a more accurate estimate, try our moving cost calculator.

Home Size	Avg. Total Cost	Cost/hour	# of Movers	# Hours
Studio	$466	$141	2 movers	3 hours
1 Bedroom	$607	$141	2 movers	4 hours
2 Bedroom	$918	$198	3 movers	5 hours
3 Bedroom	$1,984	$276	4 movers	8 hours
4 Bedroom	$2,260	$276	4 movers	9 hours
5+ Bedroom	$3,420	$387	5 movers	10 hours

Compare the top Whitefish Bay, WI movers

Let’s compare how the top movers in Whitefish Bay, WI stack up in terms of their reputation.

Company	moveBuddha rating	BBB rating	Yelp rating	Google rating
Eagle Moving & Storage Co	4.5/5	A+	2.9/5	4.2/5
Schroeder Moving Systems Inc.	4.4/5	A+	3.6/5	4/5
TWO MEN AND A TRUCK	4.4/5	A+	2.2/5	4.3/5
Hernia Movers Inc	4.3/5	A+	4.2/5	4.4/5
Brothers Moving & Storage	4.3/5	A+		4.7/5
College Hunks Hauling Junk & Moving	4.3/5	A+	2/5	4.9/5
Top Notch Moving and Storage	4.2/5	B-	1/5	4.9/5
Dreiske Moving & Storage	4.5/5	A+	3.8/5	4.5/5
Shur-Way Moving and Cartage	4.5/5	A+	3/5	4.6/5
ADCO Van & Storage, Inc.	4.6/5	A+	3.8/5	4.5/5

FAQs

How can I tell if a moving company is licensed?

Movers providing in-state relocation services in the Badger State must register with the Wisconsin Department of Transportation (WisDOT), but strictly speaking, it’s not a regulated state. However, movers must comply with individual insurance, licensing, and other state laws and regulations.

We only feature movers that are properly licensed. Take a look at our best movers in Wisconsin list to find vetted options.

What’s the best way to find a trustworthy Whitefish Bay mover?

Finding a dependable Whitefish Bay moving company can be a challenge, but there are a few key things that can help you identify a reputable mover:

Reputation: A strong reputation is important, whether the mover is a small local business or a well-established van lines company.
Dispute resolution: Steer clear of movers with a track record of unresolved complaints. While every Whitefish Bay mover may encounter customer issues, the best ones handle disputes quickly and professionally.
Experience with your type of move: Great reviews for short moves don’t guarantee success on a cross-country relocation. Make sure the mover has handled moves like yours before.

Can Whitefish Bay movers help with long-distance relocations?

While some Whitefish Bay movers stick to local moves only, 7 can help with out-of-state and long-distance relocations. If you're planning an out-of-state move, check out our list of the best long-distance movers in Whitefish Bay.

When is the most affordable day to hire movers in Whitefish Bay, WI?

Movers in Whitefish Bay, Wisconsin, are usually cheapest on weekdays, as weekends tend to be busier and more expensive. Typically, the most affordable time to move falls between October and April. Moving costs spike between May and September due to high demand during peak season.

It’s best to book your Whitefish Bay move early. To save money, try to avoid weekends, holidays, and peak summer months. And remember, a low initial quote isn’t always a good sign. Some movers increase the price on moving day after low-balling up front.

How can I move out of state from Whitefish Bay, WI on a budget?

If you're looking to save money, renting a moving truck is the most affordable way to move out of state or even locally within Whitefish Bay, Wisconsin. It’s a DIY solution, though, so you’ll be responsible for packing, loading, unloading, and doing all the driving.

Is using a moving container a smart choice for my move from Whitefish Bay?

Moving containers give you the flexibility to move on your schedule, but you’ll need to handle all the lifting and loading yourself. Once everything is packed, the container company will take care of transporting it to your new home, so you can skip the hassle of driving a moving truck.

Do movers in Whitefish Bay provide storage options?

11 moving companies in Whitefish Bay can help with both short- and long-term storage needs, while 4 also offer climate-controlled facilities to keep temperature-sensitive items safe.

Keep in mind that some movers may use third-party providers. It’s worth confirming where your items will be stored and how much it will cost before booking.

Learn more: Should you use your mover's storage solutions?