Cheapest Movers in Lancaster, NY (2025 Guide)
Fact Checked by: Quick answer: After reviewing 121 New York movers, our top pick for local moves in Lancaster, NY, is Interior Moving Services Inc based on pricing, services, and customer reviews. For long-distance and out-of-state moves from New York, we recommend Safeway Moving because they provide a good balance of quality service and affordability.
Preferred partners
Our track record
10 Cheapest movers when moving locally in Lancaster, NY
If you are moving within Lancaster or to a nearby New York city like Depew or Cheektowaga within 50 miles of Lancaster, check out these affordable, top-rated moving companies:
- Interior Moving Services Inc: 4.8 out of 5 stars
- Sheridan Brothers Moving: 4.76 out of 5 stars
- Wayfinder Moving Services : 4.66 out of 5 stars
- Clark Moving & Storage: 4.58 out of 5 stars
- Tony Caccamise Moving Co., Inc.: 4.52 out of 5 stars
- Highline Moving and Delivery: 4.52 out of 5 stars
- TWO MEN AND A TRUCK: 4.48 out of 5 stars
- Corrigan Moving Systems: 4.48 out of 5 stars
- Best Buffalo Movers : 3.9 out of 5 stars
- Pryority Movers : 3.9 out of 5 stars
Interior Moving Services Inc
rating
4.8 / 5
DOT #: 1498819
Years in Business: 32
157 La Grange Ave, Rochester, NY 14613 USMoving day becomes a breeze for most clients who choose Interior Moving Services Inc, based on 256 pieces of input. A remarkable 94% describe positive experiences—much higher than typical for the moving industry. Customers frequently mention efficient service, professional and courteous staff, careful handling of belongings, quick moving times, and genuinely friendly crews as standouts. Many appreciate how movers arrive prepared, communicate clearly, and handle even tricky items with skill and respect. Although most feedback celebrates seamless moves and competitive pricing, several clients highlight shortcomings like damage to belongings, higher bills than expected, and rare unprofessional conduct. Some mention slow work or equipment issues as negatives. Compared to other companies, Interior Moving Services earns impressive loyalty and frequent recommendations, with only a small fraction reporting unreliable or unsatisfactory experiences. Their consistent track record of punctual, personable service and safe, efficient moves clearly sets them apart.
Review Profiles
Services Offered
Move Distances
- Local moves
- Interstate moves
Available services
- Packing
- Unpacking
- Offices
- Pianos
- Hot Tubs
- Pool Tables
- Art
- Antiques
- Grandfather clocks
- Crating
- Storage
- Fragile-only packing
- Safes
Additional Information
- Pay by credit card
- Deposit Required
- DOT #: 1498819
- State license #: 32014
Sheridan Brothers Moving
rating
4.76 / 5
DOT #: 2256609
Years in Business: 22
2436 Innovation Way, BLDG 10, Rochester, NY 14607 USSheridan Brothers Moving stands out for their swift service, professional staff, and consistent care in handling belongings. Analyzing 291 pieces of feedback, about 71% of customers detailed positive experiences, often highlighting polite movers, efficient teamwork, and careful attention to property. Many clients mention that their moves finished faster than expected and rates were transparent. Still, nearly 28% of input describes issues such as damaged belongings, unfriendly or inattentive staff, and difficulties reaching the company for follow-up or claims—complaints that are more frequent here than with some top-rated national competitors. While most customers praise the team's courteous attitude and work ethic, a notable share express frustration with damage claims being unresolved or interactions that felt disrespectful. Sheridan Brothers excels at delivering prompt and friendly moves, but reliability around damage handling and communication would improve customer trust.
Review Profiles
Services Offered
Move Distances
- Local moves
- Interstate moves
- International moves
Available services
- Packing
- Unpacking
- Offices
- Pianos
- Hot Tubs
- Pool Tables
- Art
- Antiques
- Crating
- Storage
- Fragile-only packing
- Safes
Additional Information
- Pay by credit card
- Deposit Required
- DOT #: 2256609
- State license #: 34026
Wayfinder Moving Services
rating
4.66 / 5
DOT #: 3104397
Years in Business: 6
75 Comet Avenue, Buffalo, NY 14216 USMoving made simple—Wayfinder Moving Services receives glowing feedback in 91.6% of the 227 reviews analyzed. Customers frequently praise the professionalism of the staff, speedy moves, careful item treatment, and clear communication. Many say their crews are friendly, efficient, and take time to protect belongings. Wayfinder stands out by delivering consistently well-organized and courteous service, with jobs often completed quickly and at or below the quoted price. Some reviews mention affordable rates and a stress-free process. Negative input, though rare, points to damage to items, high or inaccurate estimates for certain moves, and a few cases of delayed arrivals or lack of response when issues arise. Neutral feedback highlights missed expectations for care or timing on specific jobs. Compared with other movers, Wayfinder is described as more reliable and more professional, but a few customers recommend monitoring high-value items and clarifying estimates and policies. Most found Wayfinder exceeded expectations, but details matter for the few with problems.
Review Profiles
Services Offered
Move Distances
- Local moves
- Interstate moves
Available services
- Packing
- Unpacking
- Offices
- Pianos
- Crating
- Storage
Additional Information
- Pay by credit card
- DOT #: 3104397
- State license #: 40318
Clark Moving & Storage
rating
4.58 / 5
DOT #: 125563
Years in Business: 40
3680 Buffalo Rd, Rochester, NY 14624 USTop-rated moving services often come down to details, and Clark Moving & Storage delivers on key promises. Out of 176 feedback entries, 89% praised their professionalism, efficiency, careful handling, speed, and clear communication. Most customers described polite, diligent crews who took extra care with belongings and reassured clients throughout the move. Many reviews revealed crews consistently arrived promptly and finished quickly, with smooth booking and transparent quotes. Detractors voiced concerns with a few delayed deliveries, some damaged items, and rare interactions with unfriendly staff. A handful of customers reported communication issues or broken items that weren't easily resolved. Compared to many companies, Clark stands out for reliable crews and responsive support, though improvements in damage resolution and timeliness would set a higher standard. This moving company earns strong trust for efficient, respectful service, but prospective clients should discuss delivery timelines and insurance upfront for peace of mind.
Review Profiles
Services Offered
Move Distances
- Local moves
- Interstate moves
- International moves
Available services
- Packing
- Unpacking
- Offices
- Storage
Additional Information
- Pay by credit card
- DOT #: 125563
- State license #: 10965
Alternative Business Names
- Clark Mayflower
- Mayflower Movers
Tony Caccamise Moving Co., Inc.
rating
4.52 / 5
DOT #: 967082
Years in Business: 48
051 W Main St, Lima, NY 14485 USCustomers rave about Tony Caccamise Moving Co., Inc. for professional, careful movers, efficient service, fair prices, and polite staff. Most praise attention to detail and handling of delicate items, like pianos or antiques, which places this business ahead of typical moving companies. Feedback consistently spotlights efficient crews and responsive office staff. Top concerns involve property damage, like damaged items or home surfaces, and some complaints about lack of communication or customer service follow-up. While strong positive input outweighs complaints, choosing this company means receiving experienced, courteous movers with a track record of satisfied customers and standout care handling valuables.
Review Profiles
Services Offered
Move Distances
- Local moves
Available services
- Packing
- Unpacking
- Offices
- Pianos
- Hot Tubs
- Pool Tables
- Art
- Antiques
- Grandfather clocks
- Crating
- Storage
- Safes
Additional Information
- DOT #: 967082
- State license #: 12923
Alternative Business Names
- Caccamise Moving
Highline Moving and Delivery
rating
4.52 / 5
DOT #: 1429135
Years in Business: 22
6025 Denny Dr, Farmington, NY 14425 USCustomer feedback for Highline Moving and Delivery is overwhelmingly positive, with 93% of input praising their efficient service, professionalism, attention to detail, rapid work pace, and clear communication. Clients frequently highlight the team's care in handling possessions, prompt arrival, and polite demeanor, making moves less stressful even under complex situations. Many comment that the company stands out for affordability and transparent quotes compared to similar services. Some praise how quickly issues like minor scratches are addressed by management. A small portion (6%) of feedback points to areas needing improvement, such as occasional item damage, lack of communication about claims or repairs, and instances of unexpected charges. Neutral comments mention billing errors that were quickly fixed and average professionalism. Highline ranks among the most highly regarded movers in their region, recognized for responsive, skilled crews and a reliable moving experience, though rare missteps in handling complaints and post-move issues show room for growth.
Review Profiles
Services Offered
Move Distances
- Local moves
Available services
- Packing
- Pianos
- Storage
Additional Information
- Pay by credit card
- DOT #: 1429135
Alternative Business Names
- Highline Delivery and Storage LLC.
- Highline Moving and Delivery
TWO MEN AND A TRUCK
rating
4.48 / 5
DOT #: 2527384
Consistently praised for efficient service, professionalism, and careful handling, TWO MEN AND A TRUCK earns strong feedback from those seeking reliable movers. Out of 246 customer reviews analyzed, nearly 79% were positive, reflecting above-average satisfaction compared to similar companies. Clients frequently highlight quick moves, polite teams, and clear communication. Many mention staff going the extra mile—protecting fragile items, accommodating changes, and delivering on timing. A smaller portion of feedback centers on problems such as damaged belongings, unexpected additional charges, or difficulty reaching the company regarding concerns. The most frequent issues involve property damage and dissatisfaction with billing. Customers expecting transparent costs and responsive complaint handling may encounter challenges. Positive input, however, overwhelmingly notes prompt, respectful service and movers’ attention to detail, which stands out in the industry.
Review Profiles
Services Offered
Move Distances
- Local moves
- Interstate moves
Available services
- Packing
- Unpacking
- Pianos
- Storage
- Safes
Additional Information
- Pay by credit card
- DOT #: 2527384
- State license #: 40835
Alternative Business Names
- Bulldog Movers LLC
Corrigan Moving Systems
rating
4.48 / 5
DOT #: 77949
Years in Business: 97
1845 Dale Rd, Buffalo, NY 14225 USConsistently high marks set Corrigan Moving Systems apart in a crowded industry. Out of 224 reviews analyzed, 95.5% provided enthusiastic positive feedback, with most customers praising the professionalism and courtesy of the staff. Customers frequently highlight efficient service, careful handling of belongings, and swift, organized moving processes, all supported by helpful movers throughout stressful situations. Minor dissatisfaction centers around unexpected charges, missing or lost items, and—less often—damage to property, representing only 4% of feedback. Only one neutral input offers no details about the service. Corrigan Moving’s reputation stands stronger than most moving companies, where negative feedback typically runs higher. The clear majority recommend Corrigan for efficient and professional moving experiences, though a small number note issues with billing or claims processes.
Review Profiles
Services Offered
Move Distances
- Local moves
- Interstate moves
- International moves
Available services
- Packing
- Unpacking
- Offices
- Crating
- Storage
Additional Information
- DOT #: 77949
- State license #: 779
Best Buffalo Movers
rating
3.9 / 5
Years in Business: 27
392 Genesee Street, Buffalo, NY 14204 USWord spreads fast when a moving company stands out. Out of 71 pieces of customer feedback analyzed, 91.5% gave Best Buffalo Movers glowing reports. Clients rave about efficient service, professionalism, careful handling, fair pricing, and clear communication. Teams routinely arrive on time and handle possessions with attention, which sets them apart from many competitors. Affordable rates and responsiveness add further appeal, making moves less stressful for clients. Some negative input focuses on unprofessional interactions, delays with no-shows, or poor follow-up, with a few mentioning lost items or incomplete deliveries. Such issues were rare but reflect a stark contrast to the otherwise high standards noted throughout the reviews. Compared to most moving companies, Best Buffalo Movers delivers quality service more consistently, rarely missing a beat on the aspects customers care about most.
Review Profiles
Services Offered
Move Distances
- Local moves
- Interstate moves
Available services
- Packing
- Unpacking
- Offices
- Pianos
- Pool Tables
- Storage
- Safes
Additional Information
Pryority Movers
rating
3.9 / 5
Years in Business: 6
1616 Main Street, Niagara Falls, NY 14305 USStanding out for both impressive and problematic feedback, Pryority Movers receives strong compliments for professional, polite staff, efficient moves, careful handling, and helpful movers. Customers note friendliness and readiness to handle challenging items. In contrast, several people claim the company added unexpected charges, showed up late, and treated clients rudely, with some describing unethical billing and unprofessional encounters. While some praised the team’s speed and support, more than half of the input described delayed service and billing disputes. Compared to other moving companies, customer experience with Pryority Movers has more pronounced concerns with honesty and reliability.
Review Profiles
Services Offered
Move Distances
- Local moves
- Interstate moves
- International moves
Available services
- Packing
- Unpacking
- Pianos
- Crating
Additional Information
- Pay by credit card
- State license #: 41063
Alternative Business Names
- Pryority Delivery Services
Other local NY movers
Cheapest movers when moving out of New York
Relocating from New York to a new state? You’ll need an experienced interstate moving company to get you there. Here are our recommendations:
- Safeway Moving: 4.85 out of 5 stars
- International Van Lines: 4.45 out of 5 stars
- Mayzlin Relocation: 4.9 out of 5 stars
- PODS: 4.8 out of 5 stars
- American Van Lines: 4.5 out of 5 stars
|
|
|
|
|
|
Cheapest DIY moving options in Lancaster, NY
While a full-service mover is the most convenient option for your Lancaster, New York relocation, it will also likely be the most expensive route. To save some money, you may want to consider using one of the top moving container companies, or moving truck rental companies in Lancaster instead.
|
|
|
|
|
Top-rated movers in other nearby New York cities
How we chose the best movers in Lancaster, NY
Average cost of movers in Lancaster, NY
Take a look at the pricing table below to get a general idea of the costs associated with local moves in and around the Lancaster area. For more details, you can also check out our guide on the moving costs in New York.
Please note that the moving quotes provided in the table are rough estimates, and your actual costs may differ depending on the unique needs of your move. For a more precise estimate, consider using our moving cost calculator.
| Home Size | Avg. Total Cost | Cost/hour | # of Movers | # Hours |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Studio | $619 | $269 | 2 movers | 3 hours |
| 1 Bedroom | $866 | $274 | 2 movers | 4 hours |
| 2 Bedroom | $1,466 | $372 | 3 movers | 5 hours |
| 3 Bedroom | $3,572 | $544 | 4 movers | 8 hours |
| 4 Bedroom | $4,152 | $533 | 4 movers | 9 hours |
| 5+ Bedroom | $6,430 | $730 | 5 movers | 10 hours |
Compare the top Lancaster, NY movers
Let’s compare how the top movers in Lancaster, NY stack up in terms of their reputation.
| Company | moveBuddha rating | BBB rating | Yelp rating | Google rating |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Interior Moving Services Inc | 4.8/5 | A+ | 3.7/5 | 4.8/5 |
| Sheridan Brothers Moving | 4.8/5 | A+ | 3.3/5 | 4/5 |
| Wayfinder Moving Services | 4.7/5 | A+ | 3.5/5 | 4.9/5 |
| Clark Moving & Storage | 4.6/5 | A+ | 3.3/5 | 4.6/5 |
| Tony Caccamise Moving Co., Inc. | 4.5/5 | A+ | 3.4/5 | 4.6/5 |
| Highline Moving and Delivery | 4.5/5 | A+ | 4.5/5 | 4.7/5 |
| TWO MEN AND A TRUCK | 4.5/5 | F | 1.5/5 | 4.5/5 |
| Corrigan Moving Systems | 4.5/5 | A+ | 4.2/5 | 4/5 |
| Best Buffalo Movers | 3.9/5 | A+ | 3.5/5 | /5 |
| Pryority Movers | 3.9/5 | F | 2.3/5 | 5/5 |
FAQs
How do I know if my mover is properly licensed?
How do I find a reputable Lancaster mover?
Do Lancaster moving companies handle long-distance moves?
What is the cheapest day to hire a mover in Lancaster, NY?
What is the cheapest way to move out of state from Lancaster, NY?
Are moving containers a good idea for my move from Lancaster?
What if I need help loading my moving container in Lancaster?
Do Lancaster movers offer storage?
Helpful Lancaster Resources
Lancaster Moving Services
Nearby Cities
Not what you were looking for?
Check out other categories that can help you find the information you need!
