Learn more about our Advertising Disclosure

Advertising Disclosure moveBuddha

($1,065) Movers From Indianapolis, IN to New York

Easily compare and book your next move with moveBuddha
Estimated cost & time: The cost to move 710 miles from Indianapolis, IN to New York averages $531 to $5,521. The move can take anywhere from one to six days, depending on the size, date, and distance of your move and whether you hire professional movers or handle it yourself.
Trusted by 400,000+ people who move every year
We review 3,500+ movers to help you choose with confidence
Get real-time pricing info and key industry insights

Best movers from Indianapolis, IN to New York

Best overall value
Safeway Moving Logo Safeway Moving
checkmark Best overall value
checkmark Veteran owned
checkmark Portion to charity
4.9
  • checkmarkBest overall value
  • checkmarkVeteran owned
  • checkmarkPortion to charity
American Van Lines Logo American Van Lines
checkmark Certified crews
checkmark Flat-rate pricing
checkmark Family-owned
4.5
  • checkmarkCertified crews
  • checkmarkFlat-rate pricing
  • checkmarkFamily-owned
Allied Van Lines Logo Allied Van Lines
checkmark Specialty packing services
checkmark White-glove reputation
checkmark 80+ years’ experience
4.8
  • checkmarkSpecialty packing services
  • checkmarkWhite-glove reputation
  • checkmark80+ years’ experience
Mayzlin Relocation Logo Mayzlin Relocation
checkmark Family owned
checkmark East coast focus
checkmark Affordable pricing
4.9
  • checkmarkFamily owned
  • checkmarkEast coast focus
  • checkmarkAffordable pricing
North American Van Lines Logo North American Van Lines
checkmark 1,800 trucks
checkmark Storage available
checkmark Customized moving plans
4.5
  • checkmark1,800 trucks
  • checkmarkStorage available
  • checkmarkCustomized moving plans
Professional Icon
Professional
Container Icon
Container
Rental Truck Icon
Rental truck
Freight Icon
Labor-only
Safeway Moving
checkmark Best overall value
checkmark Veteran owned
checkmark Portion to charity
American Van Lines
checkmark Certified crews
checkmark Flat-rate pricing
checkmark Family-owned
Allied Van Lines
checkmark Specialty packing services
checkmark White-glove reputation
checkmark 80+ years’ experience
Mayzlin Relocation
checkmark Family owned
checkmark East coast focus
checkmark Affordable pricing
North American Van Lines
checkmark 1,800 trucks
checkmark Storage available
checkmark Customized moving plans

Estimated cost to move from Indianapolis, IN to New York

These cost ranges are approximate estimates based on a 710-mile move from Indianapolis, IN, to New York using pricing data compiled by moveBuddha as of Nov 17, 2025. moveBuddha collects thousands of verified price points from moving companies nationwide and updates this data monthly to reflect seasonal fluctuations and market trends. Your final price may vary depending on move size, added services, parking or access challenges, fuel rates, and scheduling. We always recommend comparing quotes from multiple movers to get an accurate idea of pricing.
Studio Icon

Studio/1 bedroom

  • Full-service mover $1,478 – $3,847
  • Moving container $971 – $1,929
  • Rental truck $532 – $981
Two Three Bed Icon

2-3 bedrooms

  • Full-service mover $2,103 – $5,521
  • Moving container $1,286 – $2,545
  • Rental truck $531 – $1,142
Four Bed Icon

4+ bedrooms

  • Full-service mover $3,580 – $7,278
  • Moving container $1,810 – $3,473
  • Rental truck $719 – $1,424
Recent Moving Price Estimates
The following are real, anonymized quotes requested by moveBuddha readers in the past 48 hours. Prices change with dates and availability; use these as a ballpark, not a guarantee.
PODS
Foxcliff Estates, IN Gilbertsville, NY
2 Bedrooms
Oct 29, 2025
American Van Lines
Markleville, IN Orangetown, NY
Studio apartment
Oct 22, 2025
Mayflower Transit
Cadiz, IN Islip, NY
1 Bedroom (large)
Oct 11, 2025
Roadway Moving
Greenfield, IN Blasdell, NY
3 Bedrooms
Oct 03, 2025
North American Van Lines
Cloverdale, IN Lake Ronkonkoma, NY
Studio apartment
Sep 28, 2025
BLVD Moving
Nineveh, IN Mount Sinai, NY
2 Bedrooms
Sep 23, 2025
Allied Van Lines
Danville, IN Oceanside, NY
5+ Bedrooms
Sep 18, 2025
Budget Truck Rental
Colfax, IN Pomfret, NY
1 Bedroom (small)
Sep 03, 2025
United Van Lines
Fortville, IN Great Neck Plaza, NY
3 Bedrooms
Aug 27, 2025
Colonial Van Lines
Lawrence, IN Henrietta, NY
1 Bedroom (large)
Aug 11, 2025

Moving the opposite route? We got you covered with our moving from New York to Indianapolis, IN guide .

Local moving companies in Indianapolis

Out of 27 Indianapolis movers that can handle state-to-state moves, here are the top 5 that can handle your move to New York.

  1. Leaders Moving & Storage Co.: 4.7 out of 5 stars
  2. Sherman Moving & Storage: 4.52 out of 5 stars
  3. Planes Moving & Storage Company: 4.58 out of 5 stars
  4. Busy Bee Movers: 4.52 out of 5 stars
  5. Wheaton Moving & Storage: 4.56 out of 5 stars
https://www.facebook.com/BellhopMoving/, https://twitter.com/BellhopMoving
89.1% of all reviews were positive
9.7% of reviews were negative
Read Reviews
Review Analysis
Moving with Leaders Moving & Storage Co. means working with a crew known for professionalism, efficiency, and careful handling. Of the 248 customer responses analyzed, 89% gave positive feedback, consistently highlighting friendly staff, speedy and careful work, and helpful attitudes. Many praised the team’s ability to handle heavy or delicate items and transparency with pricing. Customers valued clear communication, organized crews, and prompt service, noting that many movers went the extra mile to ease their stress. On the other hand, roughly 10% of responses described issues such as items being damaged, inexperienced team members, and breakdowns in communication, with a few citing frustrating claims processes. A small number of customers felt that their movers lacked preparation or that management did not resolve complaints to their satisfaction. Compared to other companies in the moving industry, Leaders stands out for how often its staff receive recognition for both their skill and respectful, helpful approach. Most clients reported moves that finished on time, with their belongings arriving safely and all expectations met or exceeded.
Get a Quote (317) 280-3385

Company Info

Years in Business: 30

DOT #: 1237577

Alternate Names: L.E.A.D.E.R.S Moving & Storage Co. , Leaders Moving and Storage Company , Hilling Moving & Storage

Services Offered

  • Local moves
  • Interstate moves
  • Packing
  • Unpacking
  • Offices
  • Crating
  • Storage
  • Pay by credit card
https://www.facebook.com/BellhopMoving/, https://twitter.com/BellhopMoving
71.6% of all reviews were positive
28.4% of reviews were negative
Read Reviews
Review Analysis
Sherman Moving & Storage earns praise for a professional and courteous team, efficient service, careful handling of belongings, and a moving process many customers find fast and stress-free. Most feedback highlights their reliability, with many saying the movers protect property and provide peace of mind—a notable advantage compared to other moving companies. Users often describe the staff as friendly, knowledgeable, and highly recommended the service. On the downside, some customers report significant issues such as damages to items, especially furniture, higher costs than quoted, and unprofessional behavior from certain staff members. Concerns about billing transparency and complaint handling occasionally surface. Sherman stands out positively for its attentive staff and efficiency, but some past clients report disappointment due to unresolved damages or unexpected charges. Out of 74 reviews, 71.6% were positive.
Get a Quote (317) 784-5462

Company Info

Years in Business: 92

DOT #: 719392

Alternate Names: Ed Sherman Moving & Storage

Services Offered

  • Local moves
  • Interstate moves
  • Packing
  • Unpacking
  • Pianos
  • Hot Tubs
  • Pool Tables
  • Art
  • Antiques
  • Grandfather clocks
  • Crating
  • Storage
  • Pay by credit card
https://www.facebook.com/BellhopMoving/, https://twitter.com/BellhopMoving
89.4% of all reviews were positive
9.7% of reviews were negative
Read Reviews
Review Analysis
Planes Moving & Storage earns praise for its professional, helpful staff and efficient moving process, backed by 236 reviews with nearly 90% positive feedback. Customers often highlight careful handling of items, prompt service, and friendly movers who make the relocation much easier than with other companies. Many clients say the teams take extra steps to protect property and communicate well throughout moves. Affordability and transparent pricing also surface as advantages. In contrast, the most common complaints involve significant damage to belongings, unresolved compensation issues, and lack of communication from coordinators. Some people report surprise charges or poor response to claims. The volume and consistency of positive input position Planes ahead of most moving companies in reliability and customer satisfaction, though a few negative cases stand out for property damage and service gaps.
Get a Quote (317) 895-1444

Company Info

Years in Business: 105

DOT #: 1458935

Alternate Names: Planes Companies , Planes Specialized Logistics , Planes Commercial Services

Services Offered

  • Local moves
  • Interstate moves
  • International moves
  • Packing
  • Unpacking
  • Offices
  • Pianos
  • Pool Tables
  • Art
  • Antiques
  • Crating
  • Shipment tracking
  • Storage
  • Pay by credit card
https://www.facebook.com/BellhopMoving/, https://twitter.com/BellhopMoving
61.4% of all reviews were positive
34.3% of reviews were negative
Read Reviews
Review Analysis
Buzzing with strong feedback, Busy Bee Movers stands out for efficiency, professionalism, careful handling, speed, and affordable rates, as reflected in 61.4% positive input from 324 reviews. Customers highlight respectful teams and jobs completed on time at competitive prices. Many appreciate transparent quotes and swift, careful moves. While the moving crews earn praise for their hard work, affordable rates, and organization, 34.3% of feedback points to drawbacks such as unexpected charges, inadequate communication, and items occasionally arriving damaged. Some reviewers describe being overcharged compared to estimates, and several mention frustration when issues go unaddressed by management. Compared to other moving companies, Busy Bee Movers is celebrated for dependable staff and cost savings, but concerns about billing accuracy and responsive support set them apart as a company best suited for those willing to double-check pricing and terms in advance.
Get a Quote (317) 695-9927

Company Info

Years in Business: 34

DOT #: 573343

Services Offered

  • Local moves
  • Interstate moves
  • Packing
  • Unpacking
  • Offices
  • Pianos
  • Crating
  • Storage
  • Pay by credit card
https://www.facebook.com/BellhopMoving/, https://twitter.com/BellhopMoving
31.8% of all reviews were positive
67.8% of reviews were negative
Read Reviews
Review Analysis
Customer stories draw a sharp line between satisfaction and frequent problems at Wheaton Moving & Storage. Out of 242 reviews, less than one-third offer positive feedback. Clients typically praise careful handling, professional crews, fast moves, good communication, and efficient service. Yet most feedback details damage to items, missing or lost possessions, and poor communication—issues that outweigh positives for many customers. Compared with similar companies, complaints about lost or broken items and claim resolution are more frequent. Those seeking reliability may want to closely consider these patterns before booking.
Get a Quote (317) 842-8111

Company Info

Years in Business: 64

DOT #: 70719

Alternate Names: Crown Moving & Storage, Inc.

Services Offered

  • Local moves
  • Interstate moves
  • International moves
  • Packing
  • Unpacking
  • Offices
  • Pianos
  • Crating
  • Storage
  • Fragile-only packing
  • Pay by credit card

Local moving services in Indianapolis, IN

A quick snapshot of how many Indianapolis movers provide add-on specialty services:

Interstate
24 88.89%
Small moves
15 55.56%
Antiques
10 37.04%
Art
7 25.93%
Pianos
18 66.67%
Fragile-only packing
5 18.52%

Cost to move from Indianapolis, IN to New York

The following table outlines average prices to move from Indianapolis to New York, organized by home size and moving service.

Move size Moving company Moving container Rental
truck
Studio / 1 bedroom $1,065 – $3,493 $743 – $1,694 $527 – $904
2-3 bedrooms $2,103 – $5,521 $1,286 – $2,545 $531 – $1,142
4+ bedrooms $3,580 – $7,278 $1,810 – $3,473 $719 – $1,424

*These cost ranges are approximate estimates based on a 710-mile move from Indianapolis, IN, to New York using pricing data compiled by moveBuddha as of Nov 17, 2025. moveBuddha collects thousands of verified price points from moving companies nationwide and updates this data monthly to reflect seasonal fluctuations and market trends. Your final price may vary depending on move size, added services, parking or access challenges, fuel rates, and scheduling. We always recommend comparing quotes from multiple movers to get an accurate idea of pricing.

Cost to hire movers from Indianapolis to New York

When moving a studio or one-bedroom from Indianapolis to New York, you’ll likely pay between $1,065 and $3,493. If you have a two- or three-bedroom home, expect costs to fall somewhere between $2,103 and $5,521 for the same journey. Moving four or five bedrooms? Typical prices range from $3,580 to $7,278.

Cost of moving containers from Indianapolis to New York

When you’re heading from Indianapolis to New York, and you’re only moving a few items, you can expect to spend between $743 and $1,694. For a two- or three-bedroom place, prices usually fall between $1,286 and $2,545. If you’re packing up a large home with four or more bedrooms, the cost can range from $1,810 to $3,473. Want more details? Check out our complete PODS cost guide.

Explore the top budget-friendly moving container companies to make your move from Indianapolis easier and more affordable.

Cost of moving truck rentals from Indianapolis to New York

A moving rental truck is generally the cheapest option, but it requires you to do all of the driving and labor.

Moving a studio or one-bedroom apartment from Indianapolis to New York in a rental truck will cost around $527 to $904. A two to three-bedroom move will cost $531 to $1,142, and moving a home with four or more bedrooms costs around $719 to $1,424.

These quotes include the estimated fuel cost.

Factors influencing moving costs from Indianapolis to NY

Several factors influence the cost of movers in Indianapolis:

  • Move size: A studio move is far less expensive than relocating a large household.
  • Time of year: Higher demand in the summer season pushes up moving company rates.
  • DIY vs. professional mover: DIY options are budget-friendly but labor-intensive; hiring movers costs more but makes the process easier.

What you should know before moving from Indianapolis to NY

Moving from Indianapolis to New York brings exciting changes, though you’ll also notice a surge in living costs. Since New York often has a pricier lifestyle compared to Indianapolis, it’s wise to prepare financially.

Explore the differences between residing in Indianapolis and New York to ensure you’re ready before relocating:

Compare cost of living: Indianapolis vs. New York

Indianapolis, IN New York
Average rent $1,399 $1,507
Average home cost $220,467 $482,742
Average income (per capita) $59,110 $81,386
Cost of living index 86 100
Unemployment rate 5.6% 4.4%
State income tax 3.15% 10.9%
  • Expect to pay roughly 8% more for rent in New York compared to Indianapolis. Plan accordingly for higher housing costs.
  • Expect mortgage payments to be about 119% higher in New York than in Indianapolis, requiring some adjustments.
  • Salaries in New York are typically 38% higher than in Indianapolis, which could make it easier to cover expenses or boost savings.
  • The cost of living is about 16% higher in New York than in Indianapolis, so plan your finances carefully to handle the increase.
  • Job seekers may have an advantage in New York, where the unemployment rate is 21% lower than in Indianapolis.
  • Income taxes are 246% higher in New York than in Indiana, cutting into your take-home pay.

How life is different in Indianapolis, IN from New York

If you’re moving from Indianapolis to New York, everything from the weather and local population to the predominant political views can feel pretty different. Let’s break down what life in New York is like compared to Indianapolis.

Indianapolis, IN New York
Population 887,642 19,571,216
Political leaning Republican 49-48 Democratic 60-40
Summer high 84ºF 81ºF
Winter low 20ºF 16ºF
Annual rain 42″ 44″
Annual snow 22″ 62″
Crime index 60.71 21.51
  • In the last presidential election, New York leaned Democratic, while Indianapolis supported Republican.
  • Summer highs hover close to 81ºF in New York and near 84ºF in Indianapolis. With such similar temperatures, you’ll find adapting to the new climate relatively straightforward. Don’t forget to consider factors like humidity, overall weather dynamics, and energy usage when picturing your summer experience in the new locale.
  • In the coldest months, New York sees lows near 16ºF, and Indianapolis hovers around 20ºF. Since the conditions are alike, your expenses and daily routines should remain consistent.
  • Each year, New York sees about 44 inches of rainfall, very close to the 42 inches recorded in Indianapolis. Rain totals won’t differ much, but seasonal shifts could still shape your daily routine.
  • Each year, New York sees about 62 inches of snowfall, while Indianapolis averages just 22 inches. With more snow comes stunning winter scenery and plenty of outdoor fun, but also the need for extra preparation and warm gear.
  • With a lower crime index of 21.51, New York offers a safer environment compared to Indianapolis, which posts a higher index of 60.71.

Other considerations when moving to New York

When moving from Indianapolis to New York, think beyond just hiring movers and boxing up your stuff to keep things running smoothly. Don’t forget to check local regulations, permits, and any other logistics that could affect your move.

  • HOA rules: Some neighborhoods have specific rules for move-in days — verify with your HOA before moving.
  • Elevator reservation: Many buildings require advance booking of elevators for moves — check before your moving date.
  • Truck parking permits: Some cities require a parking permit if you’re using a moving truck or larger vehicle. Be sure to check ahead of time to see if you’ll need one for your move.
  • State licensing: New York requires moving companies to have a license and obtain a New York Department of Transportation (NYDOT) number. A NYDOT license ensures your mover is in compliance with the state’s safety, insurance, and operational regulations. Make sure the moving company you use has a license before hiring.
  • State regulator: You can check the status of a New York moving license anytime on the official state regulator’s website.
  • Moving permits: You won’t need a moving permit in New York, but it’s a good idea to check the local parking regulations ahead of your move.
  • Change of address: Be sure to fill out your USPS change of address form at least a week before your move. You can set your official move date so your mail is forwarded to New York without any hiccups. Start here.
  • Moving insurance: Insurance rules differ from state to state, so your specific needs will depend on your location. Choose Released Value Protection for no-cost, minimal coverage from movers. They’re responsible for a maximum of 60 cents per pound per article. For comprehensive coverage, discuss alternatives with your moving company or consider a third-party insurance provider.
  • Moving checklist: Peace of mind is priceless. Our moving checklist will help you know you’ve got everything covered.

Things to do in New York

No matter what you’re into—parks, museums, sports, or universities—you’ll find plenty of options to enjoy in New York.

Museums in New York

  • The National 9/11 Memorial & Museum
  • The Strong National Museum of Play
  • The Metropolitan Museum of Art
  • New York State Museum
  • Erie Canal Museum

Parks in New York

  • Brooklyn Bridge Park
  • Central Park
  • Flushing Meadows Corona Park
  • Gantry Plaza State Park
  • Robert Moses State Park

Sports teams in New York

  • Brooklyn Nets Basketball (NBA)
  • Buffalo Bills (NFL)
  • Buffalo Sabres (NHL)
  • New York City FC (MLS)
  • New York Islanders (NHL)

Universities in New York

  • Cornell University
  • Columbia University in the City of New York
  • New York University
  • University of Rochester
  • University at Buffalo, State University of New York

FAQ

How long does a move from Indianapolis to New York take?

Wondering how long your move from Indianapolis, IN to New York will take? Timing depends on the service you choose, but it typically takes one to six days. Keep in mind, if you’re moving during the busy summer months, your move might take a little longer.

If you want your move to go smoothly and avoid delays, make sure to ask about the delivery timeframe before booking your moving company.

Can I find movers that build custom crates in Indianapolis?

Yes—19 movers in Indianapolis offer custom crating, ideal for protecting artwork, antiques, and other fragile pieces. When requesting a quote, ask a Indianapolis mover about crate construction, padding, and lead times.

What is the best way to get a car from Indianapolis to New York?

Need to ship your car from Indianapolis to New York? Trust professionals who’ll protect your vehicle and manage all the details seamlessly. See our top choices for car shipping from Indiana to New York.

Why are people moving from Indianapolis to New York?

Many people are moving to New York because of its natural beauty and arts.

Read more about the Pros & cons of moving to New York.

Where can I find a list of long-distance moving companies in Indianapolis?

Can I pay for my move from Indianapolis, IN, with cash?

There are two movers in Indianapolis that accept cash payments. That said, cash is not common in the moving industry—most companies prefer card, ACH, or cashier’s check for traceability and receipts. Typically, you’ll pay a deposit to secure your booking and move date, with the remaining balance collected at pickup or after delivery (policy varies by mover). Always confirm accepted payment types and the timing of each payment before you book.

Helpful moving resources

Not what you were looking for?

Check out other categories that can help you find the information you need!

See All
Hide All
triangle triangle