McNaughton Bros Inc, Indiana, PA (2025 Review)

Ryan Carrigan
Ryan Carrigan

5 min read

McNaughton Bros Inc
140 Old Route 119 Hwy S,
Indiana, PA 15701
85% of all reviews were positive
14% of reviews were negative
Read Reviews
Review Analysis
Customers routinely praise McNaughton Bros Inc for professionalism, careful handling of items, efficient service, and a helpful staff. Out of 81 feedback instances, 85% of customers reported positive experiences, frequently highlighting smooth moves, clear communication, and staff courtesy. Many note that the team works quickly, handles possessions with care, and remains polite even under stressful conditions.
Clients especially value how the staff relieves moving-day stress and follows up post-move. The few negative comments focus on unexpectedly high final bills, damage to property, or delivery delays. Occasional complaints mention cost estimates differing from actual charges or rare mishandling of property. Compared to many moving companies, McNaughton Bros receives notably higher marks for service quality, but customers should discuss pricing details upfront to avoid surprises. Most who offered input recommend the company for reliable and respectful moving services.
Show more
Get a Quote (724) 463-3571

What customers like

85% of customers left positive reviews for Sherman Moving Company. Read a few of them below:

Google
The BEST!!! I have done 8 military moves with 8 different moving companies - none have been even cl…
Show More
Google
From scheduling to the actual move, working with McNaughton was so easy. The crew was so friendly, p…
Show More
Google
Everyone we dealt with was efficient, professional and took great care of our belongings from loadin…
Show More
Google
The staff at McNaughton Bros. made my mother's move as easy as could be. From the sales folks to th…
Show More
Google
Our move was fantastic and super easy! Everyone was very nice and easy to contact, which was great s…
Show More

Things to consider

14% of Sherman Moving Company customers left negative reviews. You can read those here:

Google
My daughter got a quote of $1,000 to move her. ... Her end payment of $1,700 was an unexpected blow.…
Show More
Google
One of our paintings was not wrapped in anything; it was just stuck in a box full of tools ... That …
Show More
Google
They just noticed that my belongings were never picked up and was just sitting in their warehouse fo…
Show More

Services

  • Local Moves
  • Intrastate moves
  • Interstate moves
  • International moves
  • Full-service packing
  • Labor-only help
  • Custom crating
  • Climate-controlled storage
  • Senior moves
  • Office moves
  • Small moves
  • Full-valuation coverage

Company info

Years in Business 105
DOT #: 120962
FMCSA Rating None
Number of trucks 15
Number of drivers 15
Miles Driven 118,463 (2022)
No deposit required
Pay by credit card
Ask for special discounts and offers

Note: If you're moving out of state, check out our list of the best long distance movers in Pennsylvania.

Cost to move with McNaughton Bros Inc

On average, the cost to hire movers in Pennsylvania is $129 an hour.

You could pay more or less with McNaughton Bros Inc depending on the specific details of your move. For an estimate of your move costs you can use our Moving Cost Calculator.

Compare with other Indiana-area movers

Company Quote Rating
crown most popular
McNaughton Bros Inc 		Get A Quote starstarstarstarstar
4.42 overall rating
crown most popular
Bellhop Moving 		Get A Quote starstarstarstarstar
4.2 overall rating
Friendly Movers LLC Get A Quote starstarstarstarstar
4.62 overall rating
Diversity Moving Company Get A Quote starstarstarstarstar
4.38 overall rating
Mike Moves Pittsburgh Get A Quote starstarstarstarstar
4.34 overall rating

Moving out of Pennsylvania?

If you are moving from Indiana, PA, to another state, finding a company that is well-versed in interstate relocations is key to having as stress-free an experience as possible.

The top interstate movers understand the particular logistics involved in out-of-state relocations and have the equipment and manpower to safely and efficiently move your belongings across state lines.

Company Quote Rating Price
Safeway Moving Inc
Safeway Moving
Get A Quote
starstarstarstarstar 4.85 / 5
dollar sign dollar sign dollar sign dollar sign
American Van Lines
American Van Lines
Get A Quote
starstarstarstarstar 4.5 / 5
dollar sign dollar sign dollar sign dollar sign
North American Van Lines
Get A Quote
starstarstarstarstar 4.5 / 5
dollar sign dollar sign dollar sign dollar sign

Cost to move out of Pennsylvaniatoggle

If you're moving out of state, here are some sample moving quotes:

Click here to see all popular moving routes.

FAQ

Is McNaughton Bros Inc properly licensed?toggle

For decades movers In Pennsylvania were regulated by the Public Utility Commission (PUC).

Each company was issued a PUC Number and was required to abide by a universal publicly published tariff that established the rates movers could charge for various services.

Now, some sources claim that the PUC no longer regulates in-state movers, and it appears as though the PUC’s website is no longer functioning. So if you’re moving within Pennsylvania, you’ll want to address these issues with your moving company representative and if possible, contact the state directly.

USDOT #: 120962.

You can also use their state regulator website to look up their active status.

Does McNaughton Bros Inc have any additional locations outside of Indiana?toggle

We were only able to find this location for McNaughton Bros Inc.

Is McNaughton Bros Inc Associated with a van line?toggle

Van lines are networks of local movers that operate separately but under the same umbrella of a multi-state organization. It's not as complicated as it sounds. Learn what van lines are.

McNaughton Bros Inc are a local affiliate of United Van Lines. Being a local affiliate to a large company means that it has the resources and reputation of United Van Lines but the attention of a local company.

Should you negotiate with Indiana movers?toggle

While haggling over moving costs isn't typically effective, there are still ways to save. Many companies offer ongoing moving discounts for groups like seniors, military personnel, and students, as well as special offers for early-bird reservations.

Getting quotes from multiple companies will also allow you to inquire about price matching. Some movers will honor lower quotes from competitors, so it doesn’t hurt to ask — and be ready to show estimates from other companies.

How do I choose a Indiana moving company?toggle

To choose the best moving company for you, start by researching reputable movers in Indiana. You'll want to be on the lookout for companies with mostly positive customer reviews, valid licenses, and comprehensive insurance to ensure your belongings are protected. Beyond that, you’ll want to make sure they can handle the type of move you need.

Ask for detailed moving quotes from at least three companies to compare services, pricing, and availability. A reliable Indiana moving company will be one that offers transparent pricing, excellent communication, and a proven track record of successful moves.

Helpful Pennsylvania resources

https://www.facebook.com/McNaughton.Brothers.Inc/, https://x.com/McNaughton1918