Learn more about our Advertising Disclosure

Advertising Disclosure moveBuddha

($994) Movers From New York to Indianapolis, IN

Easily compare and book your next move with moveBuddha
Estimated cost & time: A move from New York to Indianapolis, IN spans roughly 707 miles and averages $534 to $4,520. It generally takes one–six days, with final cost shaped by your moving date, load size, and whether you use movers or handle it yourself.
Trusted by 400,000+ people who move every year
We review 3,500+ movers to help you choose with confidence
Get real-time pricing info and key industry insights

Best movers from New York to Indianapolis, IN

Best overall value
Safeway Moving Logo Safeway Moving
checkmark Best overall value
checkmark Veteran owned
checkmark Portion to charity
4.9
  • checkmarkBest overall value
  • checkmarkVeteran owned
  • checkmarkPortion to charity
American Van Lines Logo American Van Lines
checkmark Certified crews
checkmark Flat-rate pricing
checkmark Family-owned
4.5
  • checkmarkCertified crews
  • checkmarkFlat-rate pricing
  • checkmarkFamily-owned
Allied Van Lines Logo Allied Van Lines
checkmark Specialty packing services
checkmark White-glove reputation
checkmark 80+ years’ experience
4.8
  • checkmarkSpecialty packing services
  • checkmarkWhite-glove reputation
  • checkmark80+ years’ experience
Mayzlin Relocation Logo Mayzlin Relocation
checkmark Family owned
checkmark East coast focus
checkmark Affordable pricing
4.9
  • checkmarkFamily owned
  • checkmarkEast coast focus
  • checkmarkAffordable pricing
North American Van Lines Logo North American Van Lines
checkmark 1,800 trucks
checkmark Storage available
checkmark Customized moving plans
4.5
  • checkmark1,800 trucks
  • checkmarkStorage available
  • checkmarkCustomized moving plans

Best movers by type

Professional Icon
Professional
Container Icon
Container
Rental Truck Icon
Rental Truck
Freight Icon
Labor Only
Safeway Moving
checkmark Best overall value
checkmark Veteran owned
checkmark Portion to charity
American Van Lines
checkmark Certified crews
checkmark Flat-rate pricing
checkmark Family-owned
Allied Van Lines
checkmark Specialty packing services
checkmark White-glove reputation
checkmark 80+ years’ experience
Mayzlin Relocation
checkmark Family owned
checkmark East coast focus
checkmark Affordable pricing
North American Van Lines
checkmark 1,800 trucks
checkmark Storage available
checkmark Customized moving plans

Estimated cost to move from New York to Indianapolis, IN

These cost ranges are approximate estimates based on a 707-mile move from New York to Indianapolis, IN using pricing data compiled by moveBuddha as of Dec 11, 2025. moveBuddha gathers thousands of verified moving price points from carriers across the U.S., refreshing the data every month to account for seasonality and market shifts. Your actual cost can change with factors like move size, added services, parking or access issues, fuel costs, and timing. We suggest getting quotes from several movers to understand pricing accurately.
Studio Icon

Studio / 1 bedroom

  • Moving Company $1,271 – $3,448
  • Moving Container $967 – $1,738
  • Rental Truck $470 – $976
Two Three Bed Icon

2 – 3 bedrooms

  • Moving Company $1,827 – $4,520
  • Moving Container $1,319 – $2,408
  • Rental Truck $534 – $1,114
Four Bed Icon

4+ bedrooms

  • Moving Company $3,209 – $6,859
  • Moving Container $1,766 – $3,259
  • Rental Truck $702 – $1,377
Recent Moving Price Estimates
The following are real, anonymized quotes requested by moveBuddha readers in the past 48 hours. Prices change with dates and availability; use these as a ballpark, not a guarantee.
Allied Van Lines
Cedarhurst, NY Kirklin, IN
5+ Bedrooms
Nov 04, 2025
Mayzlin Relocation
East Greenbush, NY Woodlawn Heights, IN
4 Bedrooms
Nov 01, 2025
PODS
Latham, NY Markleville, IN
4 Bedrooms
Oct 21, 2025
United Van Lines
Oriskany Falls, NY Westfield, IN
2 Bedrooms
Oct 14, 2025
Colonial Van Lines
New Hyde Park, NY Monrovia, IN
1 Bedroom (small)
Sep 29, 2025
Mayflower Transit
Washingtonville, NY Rushville, IN
1 Bedroom (large)
Sep 23, 2025
BLVD Moving
Plandome, NY Edgewood, IN
3 Bedrooms
Sep 19, 2025
American Van Lines
Plattekill, NY Country Club Heights, IN
2 Bedrooms
Sep 14, 2025
Roadway Moving
Castleton-on-Hudson, NY Zionsville, IN
Studio apartment
Sep 12, 2025
1-800-Pack-Rat
Newburgh, NY Coatesville, IN
Studio apartment
Sep 05, 2025

Moving the opposite route? We got you covered with our moving from Indianapolis, IN, to New York guide .

Local moving companies in New York

When making the move from New York to Indianapolis, IN, you’ll want skilled movers who know how to make the process easier.

Out of 130 New York movers that handle state-to-state moves, here are the top 5 that can handle your move to Indianapolis, IN.

  1. Men On The Move: 4.76 out of 5 stars
  2. Seka Moving: 4.66 out of 5 stars
  3. Al’s Moving and Storage: 4.66 out of 5 stars
  4. Piece of Cake Moving & Storage: 4.66 out of 5 stars
  5. Triangle Movers Inc.: 4.66 out of 5 stars
https://www.facebook.com/BellhopMoving/, https://twitter.com/BellhopMoving
85.3% of all reviews were positive
12.3% of reviews were negative
Read Reviews
Review Analysis
Customers rave about Men On The Move for being efficient, professional, and polite. Most feedback highlights their careful handling of belongings, quick process, and competitive rates. Many describe a stress-free experience with friendly, respectful staff and transparent communication. Issues that do arise are usually resolved quickly, setting them apart from many moving companies. Some customers report problems with damaged items, unexpected or higher-than-estimated charges, and a few mention rude staff interactions. These complaints, though less common, show that while Men On The Move consistently delivers top service for most, a small number have faced notable setbacks. With 682 reviews analyzed—85% positive—Men On The Move stands out with more reliable service, better staff, and smoother moves compared to other movers in the area.
Get a Quote (516) 373-7077

Company Info

State license #: 11671

Years in Business: 37

DOT #: 526079

Alternate Names: Men On The Move Self Storage Company, Inc.

Services Offered

  • Local moves
  • Interstate moves
  • International moves
  • Packing
  • Unpacking
  • Offices
  • Pianos
  • Art
  • Antiques
  • Crating
  • Full-valuation coverage
  • Storage
  • Pay by cash
  • Pay by credit card
  • Deposit Required
https://www.facebook.com/BellhopMoving/, https://twitter.com/BellhopMoving
84.8% of all reviews were positive
13.1% of reviews were negative
Read Reviews
Review Analysis
Seka Moving earns top marks from customers who praise efficient service, careful handling of belongings, professional and polite staff, speed, and clear communication. In 495 reviews, 85% are positive, suggesting that most find the company reliable and courteous. Feedback consistently highlights movers’ attention to protecting property and working swiftly, even with challenging jobs or tight schedules. Customers appreciate that estimates and pricing tend to be accurate. Negative input accounts for 13%, where the main complaints center on damaged items, delayed arrival or delivery, and unexpected charges after the move. These issues can be especially frustrating during long-distance relocations, where delivery windows or extra fees sometimes catch people off guard. Neutral reviews typically note reasonable moves but cite problems like slow packing or unclear fee explanations. Compared to many movers, Seka stands out for its organization, efficiency, and respectful treatment of customers’ property, but like others in this industry, a few operational or scheduling missteps sometimes occur. The company’s strength lies in its fast, attentive, and careful crews, making it a leading choice among moving services, especially for local moves.
Get a Quote (212) 203-0280

Company Info

State license #: 40118

Years in Business: 7

DOT #: 3014539

Alternate Names: Seka Moving Corporation

Services Offered

  • Local moves
  • Interstate moves
  • Packing
  • Unpacking
  • Offices
  • Pianos
  • Hot Tubs
  • Pool Tables
  • Art
  • Antiques
  • Grandfather clocks
  • Crating
  • Full-valuation coverage
  • Storage
  • Fragile-only packing
  • Pay by money order
  • Pay by cash
  • Pay by credit card
  • Deposit Required
https://www.facebook.com/BellhopMoving/, https://twitter.com/BellhopMoving
67.5% of all reviews were positive
30.8% of reviews were negative
Read Reviews
Review Analysis
Al’s Moving and Storage stands out in the local market for its efficient service and professional staff. In 354 customer reviews, 68% praised the company’s quick and careful handling of belongings. Many noted the movers’ punctuality, polite demeanor, and clear communication, highlighting seamless experiences even on complex or short-notice moves. Customers consistently mentioned that their items were packed and delivered safely, and that the company resolved most logistical challenges promptly. Some feedback points out affordable rates and transparent quoting, which sets Al’s apart from competitors frequently criticized for hidden costs. Yet, 31% of the feedback cited issues such as damaged items, unexpected charges beyond initial quotes, and poor complaint resolution. A portion reported difficulty getting compensation for losses or damages, or problems with responsiveness from office staff when things went wrong. Al’s Moving and Storage excels at delivering a streamlined, friendly service, but those concerned about damage protection or dispute resolution should clarify policies before booking.
Get a Quote (800) 766-3229

Company Info

State license #: 10492

Years in Business: 76

DOT #: 292755

Alternate Names: Al’s Moving & Storage Co. , Al & Son Moving & Storage Co. , Veral Corp. , Al’s Student Moving & Storage

Services Offered

  • Local moves
  • Interstate moves
  • International moves
  • Packing
  • Unpacking
  • Offices
  • Pool Tables
  • Art
  • Antiques
  • Crating
  • Shipment tracking
  • Full-valuation coverage
  • Storage
  • Pay by cash
  • Pay by credit card
https://www.facebook.com/BellhopMoving/, https://twitter.com/BellhopMoving
94.5% of all reviews were positive
5.0% of reviews were negative
Read Reviews
Review Analysis
Piece of Cake Moving & Storage makes relocating feel like a breeze for most customers, with 94.5% of nearly 9,000 reviews giving positive feedback. Their crews often win praise for being efficient, friendly, and showing care with belongings, making moves run quickly and protecting furniture well. Many also mention good communication and stress-free experiences, even for moves under tough conditions. Some reviewers highlight organized packing and transparent pricing as standout qualities that set Piece of Cake above their competition in major cities. Still, a small but notable group (5%) describe frustrating experiences such as item damage, surprise charges not made clear upfront, or missing boxes—and a handful share stories of items lost or mishandled during long-distance moves. A few neutral reviews point out that while customer support is responsive, the packing service can fall short of expectations. Compared to similar companies, Piece of Cake is recognized for consistent service, but it’s important for customers to ensure item lists are accurate and to monitor the moving process. For those seeking a smooth, hands-off move with careful, reliable movers, Piece of Cake comes highly recommended, but vigilance is wise to prevent issues common in the industry.
Get a Quote (212) 651-7273

Company Info

State license #: 40244

Years in Business: 6

DOT #: 3066988

Alternate Names: Piece of Cake Moving & Storage LLC

Services Offered

  • Local moves
  • Interstate moves
  • Packing
  • Unpacking
  • Offices
  • Pianos
  • Art
  • Antiques
  • Crating
  • Storage
  • Fragile-only packing
  • Pay by credit card
  • Deposit Required
https://www.facebook.com/BellhopMoving/, https://twitter.com/BellhopMoving
93.7% of all reviews were positive
5.8% of reviews were negative
Read Reviews
Review Analysis
Customer input on Triangle Movers Inc. highlights standout service with remarkable consistency. Analyzing 189 reviews shows 93.7% of feedback is positive, signaling a high satisfaction rate. Clients often mention professional and polite staff, careful handling of belongings, efficient teamwork, speed, and helpful movers. Many customers experience stress-free moves, appreciate prompt communication, and go out of their way to recommend the company. Negative input, though rare, points to issues such as damaged or missing items, unprofessional crew conduct, and lapses in communication. Some reports also include insurance claim difficulties and mishandling during delivery. Compared to others in the moving industry, Triangle Movers routinely receives praise for reliability and friendliness, with only isolated incidents of dissatisfaction—often related to rare mishaps common across moving companies. The insights provided by customers make Triangle Movers one of the most highly recommended options in its region, especially for those prioritizing careful attention and professionalism.
Get a Quote (845) 566-0288

Company Info

State license #: 33402

Years in Business: 28

DOT #: 2256609

Alternate Names: Triangle Movers, Inc

Services Offered

  • Local moves
  • Interstate moves
  • International moves
  • Packing
  • Unpacking
  • Offices
  • Pianos
  • Hot Tubs
  • Pool Tables
  • Art
  • Antiques
  • Grandfather clocks
  • Crating
  • Crane vans
  • Shipment tracking
  • Full-valuation coverage
  • Storage
  • Fragile-only packing
  • Safes
  • Pay by money order
  • Pay by cash
  • Pay by credit card
  • Deposit Required
  • DOD certified

Cost to move from New York to Indianapolis, IN

The following table outlines average cost ranges for moves from New York to Indianapolis, IN, by home size and moving service.

Move size Moving company Moving container Rental
truck
Studio / 1 bedroom $994 – $3,098 $676 – $1,722 $500 – $901
2-3 bedrooms $1,827 – $4,520 $1,319 – $2,408 $534 – $1,114
4+ bedrooms $3,209 – $6,859 $1,766 – $3,259 $702 – $1,377

These cost ranges are approximate estimates based on a 707-mile move from New York to Indianapolis, IN using pricing data compiled by moveBuddha as of Dec 11, 2025. moveBuddha aggregates thousands of authenticated price data points from movers nationwide and updates them monthly to reflect seasonal fluctuations and market dynamics. Your end price can vary by shipment size, added services, parking/access limitations, fuel costs, and timing. We suggest comparing several mover quotes to confirm pricing.

Cost to hire professional movers from New York to Indianapolis, IN

If you’re packing up a studio or one-bedroom to move from New York to Indianapolis, IN, you can expect prices to land between $994 and $3,098. For a two- or three-bedroom space, your costs will usually range from $1,827 to $4,520. If you’re moving a large four- or five-bedroom home, you’re likely looking at a price tag between $3,209 and $6,859.

Cost of moving containers from New York to Indianapolis, IN

Moving containers from New York to Indianapolis, IN, will cost you $676 to $1,722 for a small move. For a two- to three-bedroom move, moving containers can cost $1,319 to $2,408. A four-bedroom move or bigger will cost $1,766 to $3,259. Learn more about PODS cost.

Here are the cheapest moving container companies when moving out of New York.

Cost of moving truck rentals from New York to Indianapolis, IN

Renting a moving truck typically costs the least, but you’ll be responsible for both the heavy lifting and all the driving.

Expect to pay between $500 and $901 to move a studio or one-bedroom apartment from New York to Indianapolis, IN with a rental truck. For a two- or three-bedroom move, prices usually range from $534 to $1,114. If you’re relocating a four-bedroom (or larger) home, you’ll likely spend anywhere from $702 to $1,377.

These estimates factor in the average cost of fuel.

Compare local moving companies from New York to Indianapolis, IN

Here’s a quick comparison of the most popular services and discounts available for the top movers for your move:

Company Full Service Antiques Military Discount Senior Discount
Men On The Move × ×
Seka Moving × ×
Al’s Moving and Storage
Piece of Cake Moving & Storage × ×
Triangle Movers Inc. × ×

Considering the 3,180 movers we’ve assessed, take a look at how New York movers compare against the national average for services and discounts provided:

New York Nationwide
Full Service 93% 96%
Antiques 55% 46%
Military Discount 4% 4%
Senior Discount 4% 4%

Things to know before moving from New York to Indianapolis, IN

Before you grab the packing tape, let’s see how life in Indianapolis, IN stacks up against New York. We’ll cover everything, from cost of living and the social scene to daily life and can’t-miss attractions in your area.

Cost of living: New York vs. Indianapolis, IN

New York Indianapolis
Average rent cost $1,507 $1,399
Average home cost $482,742 $220,467
Average income (per capita) $81,386 $59,110
Cost of Living Index 100 86
Unemployment rate 4.4% 5.6%
State Income Tax 10.9% 3.15%
  • Rent in Indianapolis is about 7% cheaper than in New York, which means extra cash for other priorities.
  • Moving to Indianapolis means you’ll spend about 54% less on housing compared to New York, so your budget will go further.
  • Salaries in Indianapolis are typically about 27% lower than in New York. Be sure to reassess your finances and update your budget before making the move.
  • Unemployment in Indianapolis runs 27% above New York, so be proactive with networking and applications.
  • Income taxes are 71% lower in Indiana than in New York, giving you extra breathing room in your budget.

How life is different in Indianapolis from New York

Indianapolis New York
Population 887,642 19,571,216
Political leaning Republican 49-48 Democratic 60-40
Summer high 84ºF 81ºF
Winter low 20ºF 16ºF
Annual rain 42″ 44″
Annual snow 22″ 62″
Crime index 60.71 21.51
  • In the last presidential election, Indianapolis voted Republican and New York voted Democratic.
  • Summers in Indianapolis typically reach highs of 84ºF, which is comparable to the average 81ºF in New York. The temps in your new home shouldn’t come as a shock. However, be sure to consider the area’s humidity, local weather patterns, and changes in energy expenses for a complete picture of what summer will feel like in your new home.
  • During the coldest months, Indianapolis sees lows of 20ºF, about the same as New York, which hits 16ºF. With similar winter temperatures, your move should go smoothly.
  • You can expect about 42 inches of rain each year in Indianapolis, almost the same as the 44 inches you’d encounter in New York. Even though the annual rainfall is similar, different weather patterns and rainfall timing might still change up your daily routine.
  • In Indianapolis, you’ll see just 22 inches of snow each year, compared to New York, which gets 62 inches annually. Moving to Indianapolis means enjoying gentler winters, less shoveling, and fewer weather headaches.
  • Crime rates in Indianapolis are higher than in New York, with a crime index of 60.71 versus 21.51. This isn’t necessarily a dealbreaker, but it’s worth researching local safety and thinking about how it might affect your daily life.

Things to do in Indianapolis

From beautiful parks and intriguing museums to thrilling sports and excellent universities, Indianapolis can meet a wide variety of interests.

Museums in Indianapolis

  • Children’s Museum of Indianapolis
  • Indianapolis Motor Speedway Museum
  • Indianapolis Museum of Art
  • The Eiteljorg Museum
  • Indiana War Memorial

Parks in Indianapolis

  • Eagle Creek Park
  • White River State Park
  • Broad Ripple Park
  • Krannert Park
  • Skiles Test Park

Sports teams in Indianapolis

  • Indianapolis Colts (NFL)
  • Indianapolis Pacers (NBA)
  • Indianapolis Fever (WNBA)

Universities in Indianapolis

  • Butler University
  • Chamberlain University – Indianapolis
  • Crossroads Bible College – Indianapolis
  • Indiana Institute of Technology – Indianapolis
  • Indiana University – Purdue University Indianapolis

Other considerations when moving to Indianapolis, IN

  • HOA rules: Before moving day, you should review your neighborhood or community guidelines to avoid any surprises.
  • Elevator reservation: One common issue that should be handled ahead of time is reserving the building’s elevator and finding out their rules for using the elevator.
  • Parking permits: Some cities require you to get a parking permit for moving trucks, so check your new local regulations beforehand.
  • State licensing: The Indiana Department of Transportation (INDOT) regulate movers operating within Indiana and issue moving companies Indiana Households Goods Carriers Numbers. Check to make sure prospective movers have one and that it’s up to date. Make sure your moving company is fully licensed before booking.
  • State regulator: You can check your Indiana moving license directly on the state regulator’s official website, here.
  • Moving permits: You won’t need a moving permit to relocate to Indiana, but you should check local parking regulations ahead of moving day.
  • Change of address: We recommend submitting your change of address form with USPS at least a week prior to your move. You can set an official move date on the form so all of your mail will get properly forwarded to Indiana. Get started here.
  • Mover’s insurance: Opt for Released Value Protection – a budget-friendly choice with no extra cost from movers, though coverage is limited to 60 cents per pound. For instance, if a 50-inch TV weighing 25 pounds is lost or damaged, reimbursement is just $15. To ensure coverage for your items’ full value, discuss alternative options with your chosen moving company or consider third-party insurance providers.
  • Moving checklist: Peace of mind is everything. With our moving checklist, you can be sure you’re on top of every detail.

FAQ

How long does a move from New York to Indianapolis take?

The time it takes to move from New York to Indianapolis, IN varies based on where you’re starting and the type of move you pick. No matter which option you choose, loading up your stuff typically takes a day or less, even if you’re handling it on your own.

If you’re heading to Indianapolis from northern New York, expect a longer trip. When you rent a truck, budget one to two days for the drive, depending on your route and how many stops you make along the way.

Moving your belongings from New York to Indianapolis typically takes anywhere from a few days to a couple of weeks, whether you’re hiring movers or using a moving container. Make sure to ask for a delivery estimate before booking.

How far in advance should I book movers when moving from New York to Indianapolis?

Because of the 707-mile move, it’s best to book your move from New York to Indianapolis as soon as you have your moving details. Ideally, you’d book your move two to three months ahead of time.

What time of year is the cheapest to move to Indianapolis, IN?

With summer temperatures reaching 84°F and winter nights dipping to 20°F, most people make the move from New York to Indianapolis in the spring or fall. If you want to skip the crowds during peak moving seasons and potentially save some cash, consider scheduling your move in the summer or winter instead.

Helpful moving resources

Not what you were looking for?

Check out other categories that can help you find the information you need!

See All
Hide All
triangle triangle