Naglee Moving & Storage,Inc., Horseheads, NY (2025 Review)

Ryan Carrigan
Ryan Carrigan

5 min read

Naglee Moving & Storage,Inc.
1525 Grand Central Ave,
Elmira, NY 14901
74% of all reviews were positive
21% of reviews were negative
Read Reviews
Review Analysis
Moving experiences with Naglee Moving & Storage, Inc. stand out for their professional staff, fast and careful service, and responsive communication. Out of 66 pieces of customer input, nearly three-quarters praised the timely, efficient teams, and noted the company’s polite approach to handling moves. Fast-moving crews and careful treatment of belongings often set Naglee apart from many other moving companies. Still, some customers reported issues like damaged items, high costs, or missing belongings, particularly in long-distance relocations.
Problems such as unanticipated fees, lost goods, or inadequate follow-up occasionally led to dissatisfaction. While many highlighted smooth moves and prompt coordination, compared to the industry standard, complaints about damage or cost overruns were more emphasized here than with top competitors. Choosing Naglee means you’ll likely encounter a well-coordinated, courteous team, though keeping a close eye on estimates and item tracking is advisable.
Show more
Get a Quote (607) 733-4671

What customers like

74% of customers left positive reviews for Sherman Moving Company. Read a few of them below:

Google
Team worked fast and efficiently. Thanks Chris Jake and Grant!
Show More
Google
Excellent customer service, prompt replies to all questions, and jobs are done correctly.
Show More
Google
Everyone at Naglee was a pleasure to work with from start to end. Ryan, our coordinator, was there w…
Show More
Google
Movers were on time and really professional
Show More
Yelp
Naglee quickly did an in-home estimate that was accurate... Efficient in packing the day of the move…
Show More

Things to consider

21% of Sherman Moving Company customers left negative reviews. You can read those here:

Google
Multiple items are damaged. They wont stand by it and offered to pay $5.00... tons of damaged items.
Show More
Google
Do your homework... this company over estimates by double... They always bang things up.
Show More
Yelp
Many of the boxes were busted, half opened, or just smashed and broken. They didn't wrap any of our …
Show More
Google
...Four items were damaged... nine items are missing. Of the missing items, only one is of any senti…
Show More
Yelp
Every piece of furniture damaged. We contacted the Vice President of Naglee... We are simply left wi…
Show More

Services

  • Local Moves
  • Intrastate moves
  • Interstate moves
  • International moves
  • Full-service packing
  • Custom crating
  • Climate-controlled storage
  • Senior moves
  • Office moves
  • Full-valuation coverage

Company info

Years in Business 112
DOT #: 15251
FMCSA Rating Satisfactory
Number of drivers 8
Miles Driven 1 (2021)
No deposit required
Pay by cash
Pay by credit card
Pay by money order
Ask for special discounts and offers

Note: If you're moving out of state, check out our list of the best long distance movers in New York.

Cost to move with Naglee Moving & Storage,Inc.

On average, the cost to hire movers in New York is $131 an hour.

You could pay more or less with Naglee Moving & Storage,Inc. depending on the specific details of your move. For an estimate of your move costs you can use our Moving Cost Calculator.

Compare with other Horseheads-area movers

Moving out of New York?

If you are moving from Horseheads, NY, to another state, finding a company that is well-versed in interstate relocations is key to having as stress-free an experience as possible.

The top interstate movers understand the particular logistics involved in out-of-state relocations and have the equipment and manpower to safely and efficiently move your belongings across state lines.

Company Quote Rating Price
Safeway Moving Inc
Safeway Moving
Get A Quote
starstarstarstarstar 4.85 / 5
dollar sign dollar sign dollar sign dollar sign
American Van Lines
American Van Lines
Get A Quote
starstarstarstarstar 4.5 / 5
dollar sign dollar sign dollar sign dollar sign
Allied Van Lines - #5 Best Interstate Mover
Allied Van Lines
Get A Quote
starstarstarstarstar 4.75 / 5
dollar sign dollar sign dollar sign dollar sign

Cost to move out of New Yorktoggle

If you're moving out of state, here are some sample moving quotes:

Click here to see all popular moving routes.

FAQ

Is Naglee Moving & Storage,Inc. properly licensed?toggle

New York requires moving companies to have a license and obtain a New York Department of Transportation (NYDOT) number. A NYDOT license ensures your mover is in compliance with the state's safety, insurance, and operational regulations.

The state license number for Naglee Moving & Storage,Inc. is: 6656 , USDOT #: 15251.

You can also use their state regulator website to look up their active status.

Does Naglee Moving & Storage,Inc. have any additional locations outside of Horseheads?toggle

We were only able to find this location for Naglee Moving & Storage,Inc..

Is Naglee Moving & Storage,Inc. Associated with a van line?toggle

Van lines are networks of local movers that operate separately but under the same umbrella of a multi-state organization. It's not as complicated as it sounds. Learn what van lines are.

Naglee Moving & Storage,Inc. are a local affiliate of United Van Lines. Being a local affiliate to a large company means that it has the resources and reputation of United Van Lines but the attention of a local company.

Should you negotiate with Horseheads movers?toggle

While haggling over moving costs isn't typically effective, there are still ways to save. Many companies offer ongoing moving discounts for groups like seniors, military personnel, and students, as well as special offers for early-bird reservations.

Getting quotes from multiple companies will also allow you to inquire about price matching. Some movers will honor lower quotes from competitors, so it doesn’t hurt to ask — and be ready to show estimates from other companies.

How do I choose a Horseheads moving company?toggle

To choose the best moving company for you, start by researching reputable movers in Horseheads. You'll want to be on the lookout for companies with mostly positive customer reviews, valid licenses, and comprehensive insurance to ensure your belongings are protected. Beyond that, you’ll want to make sure they can handle the type of move you need.

Ask for detailed moving quotes from at least three companies to compare services, pricing, and availability. A reliable Horseheads moving company will be one that offers transparent pricing, excellent communication, and a proven track record of successful moves.

Helpful New York resources

https://www.facebook.com/NagleeGroup/?rc=p, https://twitter.com/NagleeMoving