Best Movers Near St. Marys, OH (2025 Guide)

Ryan Carrigan

Last Updated: Nov 4, 2025 • 5 min read

Fact Checked by: Hilary Snow

Among the many moving companies operating in Ohio, American Way Van & Storage rose to the top for local moves in St. Marys, OH. Our recommendation is based on 145 online reviews — 77.2% of which are positive — and a comprehensive review of 100 companies statewide.

For interstate relocations, Safeway Moving consistently impresses with their combination of service quality and overall value.

Hi, I'm Ryan.
Let's get moving.

I've helped thousands of people move over the last decade, and I can tell you that no two moves are exactly alike. Let me help you find the mover that's right for you.

Best local OH mover:

American Way Van & Storage

4.56
Best interstate mover:

Safeway Moving

4.85
Best DIY moving option:

U-Haul Truck Rental

4.15

Need more help? Build your move plan.

Get Quote

Preferred partners

Company	Quote	Rating
Safeway Moving	Get A Quote	4.85 / 5
International Van Lines	Get A Quote	4.45 / 5
Mayzlin Relocation	Get A Quote	4.9 / 5

Our track record

Each year, 400,000+ people trust our moving recommendations. Here are a few reasons why:

Founded in 2015
3,500+ moving companies analyzed
$50,000 in moving grants delivered
Up-to-date pricing info & industry data
Fact-checked for accuracy

5 Cheapest movers when moving locally in St. Marys, OH

Whether you're moving within St. Marys, relocating to nearby New Knoxville or New Bremen, or heading to another Ohio city less than 50 miles away, here are some affordable and highly-rated movers to consider:

American Way Van & Storage: 4.56 out of 5 stars
MVM Moving & Storage: 4.64 out of 5 stars
Lewis & Michael Moving & Storage, Inc.: 4.36 out of 5 stars
TWO MEN AND A TRUCK: 4.34 out of 5 stars
Mayberry's Van & Storage, Inc.: 4.38 out of 5 stars

American Way Van & Storage

1001 S. Brown School Rd. Ste. A, Vandalia, OH 45377 US

77% of all reviews were positive

22% of reviews were negative

Read Reviews

Review Analysis

Customers rave about the professionalism, careful handling, and consistently strong communication from American Way Van & Storage, with 77% of all input showing high satisfaction. Many praise the friendly teams for efficient moves and attention to detail, especially around fragile items. Quotes are typically accurate, and staff go out of their way to make the process smooth and stress-free. Some even highlight the company’s reliability as a deciding factor over competitors. A number of clients return for additional moves after positive past experiences. Negative feedback, accounting for 22% of responses, centers on damaged belongings, surprise charges, and slow or unresponsive communication when resolving issues. Claims over damaged goods or missing items sometimes take weeks or months to resolve and may end with unsatisfactory compensation. Compared to others in the moving industry, American Way stands out for customer service and staff courtesy but shares the common pitfalls of moving companies: disputes about damage and billing. 145 reviews were analyzed, showing most people feel their property is respected and the process is handled by a professional team, yet the risk of damage and unexpected costs remains.

Get a Quote (937) 898-7294

Company Info

State license #: 00139517

Years in Business: 35

DOT #: 76628

Services Offered

Local moves
Interstate moves
International moves
Packing
Unpacking
Offices
Pianos
Art
Antiques
Crating
Storage
Pay by cash
Pay by credit card
DOD certified

MVM Moving & Storage

6429 Highview Dr, Fort Wayne, IN 46818 US

97% of all reviews were positive

2% of reviews were negative

Read Reviews

Review Analysis

Customers consistently praise MVM Moving & Storage for efficient service, professional and polite teams, careful handling of belongings, quick work, and helpful movers. Out of 229 pieces of feedback, 97% reflect positive experiences. Many people highlight movers’ attention to detail and how smoothly difficult or complex moves are handled. The staff regularly receives compliments on respectful attitudes, proactive communication, and making moving much less stressful than expected. Some reviewers note that pricing is transparent and the booking process is easy, a rarity compared to competitors. Negative input, while minimal, points to incidents of damaged items, occasional unprofessional behavior, and a few cases of inaccurate estimates leading to problems on moving day. MVM Moving & Storage stands out among moving companies for its reliability and strong customer-focused approach, with only a handful of issues reported in hundreds of jobs handled.

Get a Quote (260) 203-1179

Company Info

Years in Business: 19

DOT #: 1444491

Services Offered

Local moves
Interstate moves
Packing
Unpacking
Offices
Pianos
Pool Tables
Art
Antiques
Grandfather clocks
Crating
Storage
Fragile-only packing
Safes
Pay by credit card

Lewis & Michael Moving & Storage, Inc.

3920 Image Dr, Dayton, OH 45414 US

79% of all reviews were positive

21% of reviews were negative

Read Reviews

Review Analysis

Feedback shows Lewis & Michael Moving & Storage excels in professionalism, speed, and careful handling. Out of 84 reviews, nearly 79% reflect satisfaction, praising courteous staff, efficient moves, and value pricing. Customers often describe their moving crews as respectful and quick, with many recommending the company to friends and family. Yet, about 21% of the feedback reports damaged items, frustrating wait times, and poor follow-up after issues. A small number mention lack of care with fragile goods, unexpected damage, and unresponsive communication when problems arise. Lewis & Michael stands out for efficiency and professionalism compared to typical movers, but those with valuable or delicate belongings should verify insurance and clarify expectations up front to avoid mishaps.

Get a Quote (937) 252-6683

Company Info

Years in Business: 75

DOT #: 728239

Alternate Names: Lewis & Michael, Inc.

Services Offered

Local moves
Interstate moves
International moves
Packing
Unpacking
Offices
Pianos
Pool Tables
Art
Crating
Shipment tracking
Full-valuation coverage
Storage
Pay by cash
Pay by credit card
DOD certified

TWO MEN AND A TRUCK

102 Crystal Ave Unit H, Findlay, OH 45840 US

92% of all reviews were positive

8% of reviews were negative

Read Reviews

Review Analysis

Moving days can be stressful, but Two Men and a Truck makes the process smooth. Analysis from 52 customer reviews shows that 92% praised their efficient service, speedy moving, and attentive, polite teams. Positive input highlights careful handling of fragile items, straightforward booking, and consistent follow-through. Many pointed out that moves finished faster than expected and recommended them for hassle-free relocations. On the downside, a small portion of feedback focused on unfriendly office staff and higher-than-anticipated costs. Some found quotes inaccurate compared to competitors. In contrast to similar companies, Two Men and a Truck earns standout marks for professionalism and reliability, but maintaining a friendly and transparent front desk remains important for future clients.

Get a Quote (567) 226-4116

Company Info

Years in Business: 35

DOT #: 2527384

Alternate Names: Two Men and A Truck 0315, Two Men and A Truck, Sean P. Gallagher Enterprises, Inc.

Services Offered

Local moves
Interstate moves
Packing
Unpacking
Pianos
Storage
Safes
Pay by credit card

Mayberry's Van & Storage, Inc.

1850 Cardington Rd, Dayton, OH 45409 US

84% of all reviews were positive

16% of reviews were negative

Read Reviews

Review Analysis

Exceeding expectations, Mayberry's Van & Storage, Inc. receives strong support from its customers. Out of 32 reviews examined, 84% offered positive input, with customers noting professional movers, careful handling of belongings, efficiency, reasonable rates, and frequent recommendations to friends and family. People highlight the staff's politeness and consistent service quality. Negative feedback is rare but centers on serious problems, such as lost or damaged items, unexpected billing differences, and difficulty communicating with the company. Most movers in this industry struggle to match this level of satisfaction, making Mayberry's a standout choice for reliability and professionalism, with only a small share of unresolved issues reported.

Get a Quote (937) 298-8800

Company Info

Years in Business: 80

DOT #: 81407

Services Offered

Local moves
Interstate moves
International moves
Packing
Unpacking
Offices
Pianos
Pool Tables
Art
Crating
Shipment tracking
Storage
Safes
Pay by money order
Pay by cash
Pay by credit card
DOD certified

Other local OH movers

While these local Ohio movers did not make our top list, they are still worth looking into:

Top-rated movers in other nearby Ohio cities

If the service you need isn't available nearby, you can still find top-rated movers in other parts of OH that may offer exactly what you're looking for.

See less

Cheapest movers when moving out of Ohio

Relocating from Ohio to a new state? You’ll need an experienced interstate moving company to get you there. Here are our recommendations:

Safeway Moving: 4.85 out of 5 stars
International Van Lines: 4.45 out of 5 stars
Mayzlin Relocation: 4.9 out of 5 stars
PODS: 4.8 out of 5 stars
American Van Lines: 4.5 out of 5 stars

Safeway Moving

rating

4.85 / 5

Licensed

Insured

Price

Best overall value
Portion to charity
Veteran owned

Get A Quote

(855) 650-0657

International Van Lines

rating

4.45 / 5

Licensed

Insured

Price

24/7 cust. service
Competitive rates
10% discounts

Get A Quote

(855) 929-4120

Mayzlin Relocation

rating

4.9 / 5

Licensed

Insured

Price

Family owned
East coast focus
Affordable pricing

Get A Quote

(980) 217-6841

PODS

rating

4.8 / 5

Licensed

Insured

Price

Unlimited storage
3 container sizes
10% discount

Get A Quote

Visit Website

American Van Lines

rating

4.5 / 5

Licensed

Insured

Price

Certified crews
Flat-rate pricing
Family-owned

Get A Quote

866-835-2392

Cheapest DIY moving options in St. Marys, OH

Going with a full-service mover for your St. Marys, Ohio move is the easiest way to go. That convenience can be costly, however. To keep moving costs lower, consider using one of the leading moving container companies, or a rental truck provider in St. Marys.

PODS

rating

4.8 / 5

Licensed

Insured

Price

Unlimited storage
3 container sizes
10% discount

Get A Quote

Visit Website

U-Pack

rating

5 / 5

Licensed

Insured

Price

Fast delivery
Nationwide
100+ miles moves

Check prices Visit Website

MovingYourself

rating

4.5 / 5

Licensed

Insured

Price

Affordable pricing
Offers car shipping
No hidden fees

Get A Quote

(352) 322-2920

Budget Truck Rental

rating

4.3 / 5

Licensed

Insured

Price

Affordable pricing
Online pricing
Several discounts

Check prices Visit Website

How we chose the best movers in St. Marys, OH

moveBuddha’s expert team analyzed moving rates from 68 Ohio movers and listed the top five best movers based on customer satisfaction, reviews, and cost.

Customer satisfaction (40%): The company consistently delivers services in a timely matter with good communication and within the estimated cost.

Dispute resolution (20%): Mistakes cannot be avoided in the moving industry. We look for companies that own their mistakes and make genuine efforts to fix any issues that arise during a move.

Industry reputation (15%): The company is well-regarded within the moving industry and participates in industry conferences and organizations.

Online reputation (15%): The company maintains a professional website with accurate information. The company promptly and professionally responds to online customer inquiries.

Service options (10%): We look for companies with a deep breadth of services including full packing, storage, specialty item handling, and expedited delivery.

Here is our full moving company rating methodology.

Average cost of movers in St. Marys, OH

Use the pricing table below to get a general sense of what local moving costs look like in and around St. Marys. If you want more in-depth info, check out our full guide on moving costs in Ohio.

Keep in mind that the moving quotes provided are just rough estimates. Your actual cost will depend on the specifics of your move. For a more accurate estimate, use our moving cost calculator.

Home Size	Avg. Total Cost	Cost/hour	# of Movers	# Hours
Studio	$506	$192	2 movers	3 hours
1 Bedroom	$698	$192	2 movers	4 hours
2 Bedroom	$1,119	$269	3 movers	5 hours
3 Bedroom	$2,572	$376	4 movers	8 hours
4 Bedroom	$2,948	$376	4 movers	9 hours
5+ Bedroom	$4,532	$527	5 movers	10 hours

Compare the top St. Marys, OH movers

Let’s compare how the top movers in St. Marys, OH stack up in terms of their reputation.

Company	moveBuddha rating	BBB rating	Yelp rating	Google rating
American Way Van & Storage	4.6/5	A+	1.8/5	4.3/5
MVM Moving & Storage	4.6/5	A+	5/5	4.9/5
Lewis & Michael Moving & Storage, Inc.	4.4/5	A+	3.4/5	4.2/5
TWO MEN AND A TRUCK	4.3/5	A+	5/5	4.5/5
Mayberry's Van & Storage, Inc.	4.4/5	A+	4.4/5	4.2/5
Hoover the Mover	4.3/5	A+	2.8/5	4.2/5
Greater Dayton Moving & Storage	4.3/5	A+	2.7/5	4.2/5
Callan & Woodworth Moving & Storage	4.3/5	A+	1.8/5	4.4/5
Lincoln Storage & Moving Inc	4.3/5	A+	1/5	3.9/5
My Movers Inc.	4.2/5	A+	3.8/5	5/5

FAQs

How can I tell if a moving company is licensed?

Although a local license is not required in Ohio, make sure the moving company you’ll be hiring is registered with U.S. Department of Transportation (USDOT). To verify if you’re dealing with a legal and licensed mover, you may ask them their USDOT registration number.

All movers included in our listings hold the proper licenses. Visit our best movers in Ohio roundup for suggestions.

How do I find a reputable St. Marys mover?

Looking for a reliable St. Marys moving company can be difficult, but there are certain things to consider to ensure you choose a trustworthy mover. These include:

Reputation: A mover's reputation is crucial, whether they're a new mom-and-pop business or a seasoned van lines company.
Dispute resolution: It's best to avoid movers with lots of unresolved customer complaints. Every St. Marys moving company will face customer issues. The best companies resolve customer disputes in a timely manner.
Relevant experience: Even if a mover has great reviews for local moves, they may not have the experience needed to handle a cross-country move. Check if they have experience with the type of move you require.

What day is usually the least expensive to move in St. Marys, OH?

The most budget-friendly days to hire movers in St. Marys, Ohio, are weekdays, since demand tends to be higher on weekends. Generally, the least expensive time to move is during the off-season from October to April. Expect higher rates from May through September due to peak demand.

Booking early is key if you’re planning a move from St. Marys. For the best deal, steer clear of weekends, holidays, and the busy summer months. Be cautious with quotes that seem too low—some movers may hike the price significantly on moving day.

What’s the most cost-effective way to move from St. Marys, OH to another state?

Renting a truck is typically the cheapest option for moving out of state or around St. Marys, Ohio. Just keep in mind that it's a no-frills option. You’ll need to take care of all the packing, loading, unloading, and driving yourself.

Should I consider a moving container for my move from St. Marys?

Moving containers are a convenient option if you prefer a flexible schedule. Just be ready to handle the loading and unloading yourself. Once you're packed up, the company picks up the container and delivers it to your new place — no need to worry about driving.