Cheapest Movers in New Columbus, PA (2025 Guide)

Quick answer: After comparing 87 moving companies in Pennsylvania, our recommended local mover in New Columbus, PA, is Bellhop Moving thanks to their pricing, variety of moving solutions, and great customer reviews. Safeway Moving earns our top pick for out-of-state or long-distance moves from Pennsylvania because they are affordable without cutting corners on service.

ryan carrigan moving expert
Hi, I'm Ryan.
Let's get moving.
I've helped thousands of people move over the last decade, and I can tell you that no two moves are exactly alike. Let me help you find the mover that's right for you.
I've helped thousands of people move over the last decade, and I can tell you that no two moves are exactly alike. Let me help you find the mover that's right for you.
Need more help? Build your move plan.
Get Quote

Preferred partners

Our track recordtoggle

Recommended by Time Magazine
Recommended by The New York Times
Recommended by Forbes
Recommended by Money.com
Recommended by Consumer Reports
Recommended by Time Magazine
Recommended by The New York Times
Recommended by Forbes
Recommended by Money.com
Recommended by Consumer Reports

Each year, 400,000+ people trust our moving recommendations. Here are a few reasons why:

  • Founded in 2015
  • 3,500+ moving companies analyzed
  • $50,000 in moving grants delivered
  • Up-to-date pricing info & industry data
  • Fact-checked for accuracy

6 Cheapest movers when moving locally in New Columbus, PA

Whether you're moving within New Columbus, relocating to nearby Stillwater or Benton, or heading to another Pennsylvania city less than 50 miles away, here are some affordable and highly-rated movers to consider:

Preferred Partner
Bellhop Moving: 4.2 out of 5 stars

Other top partners:
https://www.facebook.com/BellhopMoving/, https://twitter.com/BellhopMoving
Customer Praise
  • Professional and polite staff (32%)
  • Efficient service (30%)
  • Good communication (27%)
Customer Complaints
  • Delayed arrival or delivery (35%)
  • Unexpected charges (31%)
  • Damage to items (29%)
Review Analysis
Bellhop Moving earns strong marks for efficiency, professional and approachable crews, and quick, careful service. Customer feedback highlights that moves often proceed swiftly, with friendly staff showing respect for property and maintaining positive attitudes. Many users note their belongings remained intact thanks to careful handling, and movers frequently finished ahead of schedule. In contrast, several customers faced delays, unexpected scheduling issues, and items damaged during moves. Coordination problems between Bellhop’s office and actual movers led to missed appointments or late teams more often than with traditional moving companies. Compared to others in the industry, Bellhop stands out for affordable, rapid moves when everything goes as planned, but lacks consistent reliability during peak times or for complex moves.
Get a Quote (866) 774-5063

Company Info

State license #: 2878240

DOT #: 2878240


Services Offered

  • Local moves
  • Interstate moves
  • Packing
  • Unpacking
  • Storage
  • Pay by credit card
  • Deposit Required
https://www.facebook.com/GoArmstrongLancaster/, https://twitter.com/Arm_Lancaster
Customer Praise
  • Efficient service (36%)
  • Professional and polite staff (32%)
  • Careful handling (30%)
Customer Complaints
  • Damage to items (25%)
  • Unexpected charges (22%)
  • Delayed arrival or delivery (20%)
Review Analysis
Customers often call Armstrong Relocation the gold standard of moving. Out of 225 reviews analyzed, more than 90% featured positive feedback. Most praise the team's professionalism, attention to detail, speed, careful handling, and responsive communication. Crews consistently arrive on time, treat belongings and homes with respect, and finish quickly. Many note estimates are accurate, and several say Armstrong's pricing beats competitors. On the downside, a handful of customers report property damage and long waits for claim resolution. Some cite trouble reaching staff or unexpected extra costs. Compared with industry standards, Armstrong receives far fewer serious complaints, and its teams are routinely described as the most professional movers customers have hired. The company earns strong trust and repeat business, with negative feedback mostly centered on damage claims, rare billing issues, or isolated incidents of poor communication.
Get a Quote (717) 492-4155

Company Info

State license #: 8917264

Years in Business: 74

DOT #: 1170867

Alternate Names: Jack Treier Moving & Storage


Services Offered

  • Local moves
  • Interstate moves
  • International moves
  • Packing
  • Unpacking
  • Offices
  • Pianos
  • Art
  • Antiques
  • Storage
  • Fragile-only packing
  • Pay by credit card
https://www.facebook.com/ZippyShellGreaterPhiladelphia, https://twitter.com/ZippyShellPHL
Customer Praise
  • Efficient service (25%)
  • Professional and polite staff (22%)
  • Good communication (20%)
Customer Complaints
  • Damage to items (30%)
  • Delayed arrival or delivery (24%)
  • Unexpected charges (22%)
Review Analysis
Moving made easy: Zippy Shell earns high marks for efficient service and friendly professionals, with 90.5% of the 262 feedback pieces praising attentive, careful crews and responsive communication. Customers frequently highlighted the team's speed, respectfulness, and skill in handling belongings, making moves stress-free. Many cited extra care, especially for fragile items, along with prompt arrivals and transparent, affordable pricing—often seen as superior to typical competitors. Negative input centers on damage to possessions, delayed delivery or pickup, and occasional poor communication, especially when dealing with claims or customer support. Though critical complaints made up less than 10% of input, these issues affected satisfaction deeply when they occurred. Zippy Shell stands out for affordability and strong moving crews, though better consistency handling damage claims and schedules would align the service with top-tier moving experiences.
Get a Quote (484) 220-0499

Company Info

Years in Business: 7

DOT #: 3060008

Alternate Names: Masha Mobile Moving and Storage, LLC


Services Offered

  • Local moves
  • Interstate moves
  • Packing
  • Unpacking
  • Offices
  • Pianos
  • Hot Tubs
  • Pool Tables
  • Art
  • Antiques
  • Crating
  • Storage
  • Safes
  • Pay by cash
  • Pay by credit card
  • Deposit Required
https://www.facebook.com/people/Geo-W-Weaver-Son-Inc/100090270632783/?paipv=0&eav=AfamJb_pv9ffgPJWM7SohjCagQW6r-npdon84gTVF9MGbc0PAmBbKRIJ4W1rMs4KVR4&_rdr,
Customer Praise
  • Professional and polite staff (45%)
  • Efficient service (40%)
  • Careful handling (38%)
Customer Complaints
  • Damage to items (25%)
  • Lack of communication (20%)
  • Unexpected charges (18%)
Review Analysis
Moving with Geo. W. Weaver & Sons Inc. means working with a team known for efficiency, professionalism, and careful service. Out of 259 reviews, 92.7% report positive experiences, making this company a standout in the moving industry. Customers consistently mention the staff’s courtesy, professionalism, and attention to detail. Moves are often completed quickly and without issue, and communication from the office to the moving crew earns praise for keeping customers informed and at ease. On the flip side, a few clients have faced issues like damaged items, inaccurate quotes, and communication breakdowns. Complaints about property damage and unexpected costs are more frequent than with similar services. Despite some negative feedback, the vast majority of input highlights reliability, speed, and a crew that takes extra care with belongings.
Get a Quote (717) 774-7838

Company Info

State license #: 702302

Years in Business: 127

DOT #: 10676

Alternate Names: Harrisburg Storage Co., M.F. Rockey Moving Company, Penn Hershey Transfer, Harrisburg Transfer Company, George W. Weaver


Services Offered

  • Local moves
  • Interstate moves
  • International moves
  • Packing
  • Unpacking
  • Offices
  • Pianos
  • Art
  • Antiques
  • Crating
  • Full-valuation coverage
  • Storage
  • Pay by credit card
https://www.facebook.com/MovingStorageRigging,
Customer Praise
  • Efficient service (32%)
  • Professional and polite staff (27%)
  • Good communication (24%)
Customer Complaints
  • Damage to items (29%)
  • Delayed arrival or delivery (23%)
  • Unexpected charges (20%)
Review Analysis
Rave reviews set Dimon & Bacorn Company of Binghamton apart, with 132 customer feedback entries showing 88% reporting positive experiences. Clients repeatedly mention professional, courteous staff, swift moves, careful handling of items, and outstanding communication. Moving teams arrive on time, work efficiently, and keep customers well-informed, making moves less stressful. Helpful staff and responsive office coordination are highlighted across dozens of comments. On the flip side, a handful of clients report serious problems, including broken items, inaccurate cost estimates, and difficulty contacting staff or getting claims resolved. Despite these negatives, the proportion of satisfied customers places Dimon & Bacorn well above industry averages for both professionalism and reliability.
Get a Quote (607) 734-2937

Company Info

State license #: 4053

Years in Business: 124

DOT #: 15010

Alternate Names: Pettis Moving Co. Inc., Dimon & Bacorn Company


Services Offered

  • Local moves
  • Interstate moves
  • International moves
  • Packing
  • Unpacking
  • Offices
  • Pianos
  • Art
  • Antiques
  • Grandfather clocks
  • Crating
  • Shipment tracking
  • Full-valuation coverage
  • Storage
  • Fragile-only packing
  • Pay by money order
  • Pay by cash
  • Pay by credit card
https://www.facebook.com/NagleeGroup/?rc=p, https://twitter.com/NagleeMoving
Customer Praise
  • Efficient service (32%)
  • Professional and polite staff (27%)
  • Good communication (24%)
Customer Complaints
  • Damage to items (30%)
  • Unexpected charges (20%)
  • Lack of communication (15%)
Review Analysis
Moving experiences with Naglee Moving & Storage, Inc. stand out for their professional staff, fast and careful service, and responsive communication. Out of 66 pieces of customer input, nearly three-quarters praised the timely, efficient teams, and noted the company’s polite approach to handling moves. Fast-moving crews and careful treatment of belongings often set Naglee apart from many other moving companies. Still, some customers reported issues like damaged items, high costs, or missing belongings, particularly in long-distance relocations. Problems such as unanticipated fees, lost goods, or inadequate follow-up occasionally led to dissatisfaction. While many highlighted smooth moves and prompt coordination, compared to the industry standard, complaints about damage or cost overruns were more emphasized here than with top competitors. Choosing Naglee means you’ll likely encounter a well-coordinated, courteous team, though keeping a close eye on estimates and item tracking is advisable.
Get a Quote (607) 733-4671

Company Info

State license #: 6656

Years in Business: 112

DOT #: 15251

Alternate Names: Naglee Fine Arts Storage


Services Offered

  • Local moves
  • Interstate moves
  • International moves
  • Packing
  • Unpacking
  • Offices
  • Pianos
  • Art
  • Antiques
  • Crating
  • Shipment tracking
  • Full-valuation coverage
  • Storage
  • Pay by money order
  • Pay by cash
  • Pay by credit card
  • DOD certified

Other local PA moverstoggle

While these local Pennsylvania movers did not make our top list, they are still worth looking into:

Cheapest movers when moving out of Pennsylvania

Moving from Pennsylvania to another state involves more than just packing boxes. You’ll also need the support of an experienced moving team. These interstate moving companies have the know-how and manpower to make your move as easy as possible:

  1. Safeway Moving: 4.85 out of 5 stars
  2. International Van Lines: 4.45 out of 5 stars
  3. Mayzlin Relocation: 4.9 out of 5 stars
  4. PODS: 4.8 out of 5 stars
  5. American Van Lines: 4.5 out of 5 stars
moveBuddha logo iconrating starstarstarstarstar 4.85 / 5
Licensedcheckmark
Insuredcheckmark
Price dollar sign dollar sign dollar sign dollar sign
  • Best overall value
  • Portion to charity
  • Veteran owned
moveBuddha logo iconrating starstarstarstarstar 4.45 / 5
Licensedcheckmark
Insuredcheckmark
Price dollar sign dollar sign dollar sign dollar sign
  • 24/7 cust. service
  • Competitive rates
  • 10% discounts
moveBuddha logo iconrating starstarstarstarstar 4.9 / 5
Licensedcheckmark
Insuredcheckmark
Price dollar sign dollar sign dollar sign dollar sign
  • Family owned
  • East coast focus
  • Affordable pricing
moveBuddha logo iconrating starstarstarstarstar 4.8 / 5
Licensedcheckmark
Insuredcheckmark
Price dollar sign dollar sign dollar sign dollar sign
  • Unlimited storage
  • 3 container sizes
  • 10% discount
moveBuddha logo iconrating starstarstarstarstar 4.5 / 5
Licensedcheckmark
Insuredcheckmark
Price dollar sign dollar sign dollar sign dollar sign
  • Certified crews
  • Flat-rate pricing
  • Family-owned

Cheapest DIY moving options in New Columbus, PA

Choosing a full-service mover for your New Columbus, Pennsylvania move is definitely the most convenient option, but it’s also usually the priciest. If you’re looking to cut costs, consider going with one of the top moving container companies. Or, check out moving truck rental companies in New Columbus instead.

moveBuddha logo iconrating starstarstarstarstar 4.8 / 5
Licensedcheckmark
Insuredcheckmark
Price dollar sign dollar sign dollar sign dollar sign
  • Unlimited storage
  • 3 container sizes
  • 10% discount
moveBuddha logo iconrating starstarstarstarstar 5 / 5
Licensedcheckmark
Insuredcheckmark
Price dollar sign dollar sign dollar sign dollar sign
  • Fast delivery
  • Nationwide
  • 100+ miles moves
moveBuddha logo iconrating starstarstarstarstar 4.5 / 5
Licensedcheckmark
Insuredcheckmark
Price dollar sign dollar sign dollar sign dollar sign
  • Affordable pricing
  • Offers car shipping
  • No hidden fees
moveBuddha logo iconrating starstarstarstarstar 4.3 / 5
Licensedcheckmark
Insuredcheckmark
Price dollar sign dollar sign dollar sign dollar sign
  • Affordable pricing
  • Online pricing
  • Several discounts

Top-rated movers in other nearby Pennsylvania cities

See more
See less

How we chose the best movers in New Columbus, PAtoggle

moveBuddha’s expert team analyzed moving rates from 87 Pennsylvania movers and listed the top five best movers based on customer satisfaction, reviews, and cost.

Customer satisfaction (40%): The company consistently delivers services in a timely matter with good communication and within the estimated cost.

Dispute resolution (20%): Mistakes cannot be avoided in the moving industry. We look for companies that own their mistakes and make genuine efforts to fix any issues that arise during a move.

Industry reputation (15%): The company is well-regarded within the moving industry and participates in industry conferences and organizations.

Online reputation (15%): The company maintains a professional website with accurate information. The company promptly and professionally responds to online customer inquiries.

Service options (10%): We look for companies with a deep breadth of services including full packing, storage, specialty item handling, and expedited delivery.

Here is our full moving company rating methodology.

Average cost of movers in New Columbus, PA

Use the pricing table below to get a general sense of what local moving costs look like in and around New Columbus. If you want more in-depth info, check out our full guide on moving costs in Pennsylvania.

Keep in mind that the moving quotes provided are just rough estimates. Your actual cost will depend on the specifics of your move. For a more accurate estimate, use our moving cost calculator.

Home Size Avg. Total Cost Cost/hour # of Movers # Hours
Studio $609 $207 2 movers 3 hours
1 Bedroom $798 $212 2 movers 4 hours
2 Bedroom $1,279 $293 3 movers 5 hours
3 Bedroom $2,790 $402 4 movers 8 hours
4 Bedroom $3,259 $402 4 movers 9 hours
5+ Bedroom $4,981 $586 5 movers 10 hours

Compare the top New Columbus, PA movers

Let’s compare how the top movers in New Columbus, PA stack up in terms of their reputation.

Company moveBuddha rating BBB rating Yelp rating Google rating
Armstrong relocation 4.8/5 A+ 3.4/5 4.7/5
Zippy Shell 4.7/5 A 3.8/5 4.6/5
Geo. W. Weaver & Sons Inc. 4.7/5 A+ 3.9/5 4.9/5
Dimon & Bacorn Company of Binghamton 4.6/5 A+ 4.6/5 4.5/5
Naglee Moving & Storage,Inc. 4.6/5 A+ 2.3/5 4.3/5
TWO MEN AND A TRUCK 4.5/5 A+ 3/5 3.9/5
Adam Meyer Moving & Storage 4.5/5 A+ 4.1/5
Shively's Moving and Storage 4.5/5 A+ 4.1/5 4.8/5
NorthEastern Movers Inc. 4.4/5 A+ 4.4/5 4.7/5
Brier Moving Co. 4.2/5 NR 5/5 5/5

FAQs

How can I verify if my mover is legally licensed?toggle

For decades movers In Pennsylvania were regulated by the Public Utility Commission (PUC). Each company was issued a PUC Number and was required to abide by a universal publicly published tariff that established the rates movers could charge for various services. Now, some sources claim that the PUC no longer regulates in-state movers, and it appears as though the PUC’s website is no longer functioning. So if you’re moving within Pennsylvania, you’ll want to address these issues with your moving company representative and if possible, contact the state directly.

Every mover featured in our guide is fully licensed. Check out our best movers in Pennsylvania page for top picks.

What’s the best way to find a trustworthy New Columbus mover?toggle

Finding a dependable New Columbus moving company can be a challenge, but there are a few key things that can help you identify a reputable mover:

  • Reputation: A strong reputation is important, whether the mover is a small local business or a well-established van lines company.
  • Dispute resolution: Steer clear of movers with a track record of unresolved complaints. While every New Columbus mover may encounter customer issues, the best ones handle disputes quickly and professionally.
  • Experience with your type of move: Great reviews for short moves don’t guarantee success on a cross-country relocation. Make sure the mover has handled moves like yours before.

Can New Columbus movers help with long-distance relocations?toggle

Some moving companies in New Columbus offer long-distance services, while others stick to local moves only. If you're planning an out-of-state move, check out our list of the best long distance movers in New Columbus.

When is the most affordable day to hire movers in New Columbus, PA?toggle

Movers in New Columbus, Pennsylvania, are usually cheapest on weekdays, as weekends tend to be busier and more expensive. Typically, the most affordable time to move falls between October and April. Moving costs spike between May and September due to high demand during peak season.

It’s best to book your New Columbus move early. To save money, try to avoid weekends, holidays, and peak summer months. And remember, a low initial quote isn’t always a good sign. Some movers increase the price on moving day after low-balling up front.

How can I move out of state from New Columbus, PA on a budget?toggle

If you're looking to save money, renting a moving truck is the most affordable way to move out of state or even locally within New Columbus, Pennsylvania. It’s a DIY solution, though, so you’ll be responsible for packing, loading, unloading, and doing all the driving.

Is using a moving container a smart choice for my move from New Columbus?toggle

Moving containers give you the flexibility to move on your schedule, but you’ll need to handle all the lifting and loading yourself. Once everything is packed, the container company will take care of transporting it to your new home, so you can skip the hassle of driving a moving truck.

Can I get help loading my moving container in New Columbus?toggle

If you’re going the DIY route with a rental truck or container, labor-only moving companies are a great way to get some extra help. Hiring professionals to assist with loading and unloading can lighten the workload and speed up the process.

Can I get storage from New Columbus moving companies?toggle

Many New Columbus movers offer both short- and long-term storage options. Some companies may rely on third-party storage facilities, so be sure to ask how and where your belongings will be stored. It’s a good idea to confirm availability and costs when comparing movers.

Learn more: Should you use your mover's storage solutions?

Helpful New Columbus Resources

Not what you were looking for?

Check out other categories that can help you find the information you need!

See All
Hide All