Learn more about our Advertising Disclosure

Advertising Disclosure moveBuddha

($994) Cost to Move From New York City, NY to Indianapolis, IN

Easily compare and book your next move with moveBuddha
Estimated cost & time: The cost for moving 707 miles from New York City to Indianapolis is generally between $534 and $4,520. The trip duration should be approximately one–six days. Final cost is influenced by distance, date, the size of your home, and whether you opt for DIY or professional movers.
Trusted by 400,000+ people who move every year
We review 3,500+ movers to help you choose with confidence
Get real-time pricing info and key industry insights

Best movers from New York City to Indianapolis

Best overall value
Safeway Moving Logo Safeway Moving
checkmark Best overall value
checkmark Veteran owned
checkmark Portion to charity
4.9
  • checkmarkBest overall value
  • checkmarkVeteran owned
  • checkmarkPortion to charity
American Van Lines Logo American Van Lines
checkmark Certified crews
checkmark Flat-rate pricing
checkmark Family-owned
4.5
  • checkmarkCertified crews
  • checkmarkFlat-rate pricing
  • checkmarkFamily-owned
North American Van Lines Logo North American Van Lines
checkmark 1,800 trucks
checkmark Storage available
checkmark Customized moving plans
4.5
  • checkmark1,800 trucks
  • checkmarkStorage available
  • checkmarkCustomized moving plans
Allied Van Lines Logo Allied Van Lines
checkmark Specialty packing services
checkmark White-glove reputation
checkmark 80+ years’ experience
4.8
  • checkmarkSpecialty packing services
  • checkmarkWhite-glove reputation
  • checkmark80+ years’ experience
Mayzlin Relocation Logo Mayzlin Relocation
checkmark Family owned
checkmark East coast focus
checkmark Affordable pricing
4.9
  • checkmarkFamily owned
  • checkmarkEast coast focus
  • checkmarkAffordable pricing

Best movers by type

Professional Icon
Professional
Container Icon
Container
Rental Truck Icon
Rental Truck
Freight Icon
Labor Only

Best professional movers from New York City to Indianapolis

When it comes to handling your interstate move from New York City to Indianapolis, entrusting professionals with the details is often the best decision. Full-service movers are equipped to manage everything, allowing you to concentrate on settling into your new place.

In New York City, you have a choice of 152 interstate moving companies. Let us introduce you to our top recommendations that will help you reach Indianapolis smoothly and with confidence.

Safeway Moving
checkmark Best overall value
checkmark Veteran owned
checkmark Portion to charity
American Van Lines
checkmark Certified crews
checkmark Flat-rate pricing
checkmark Family-owned
Allied Van Lines
checkmark Specialty packing services
checkmark White-glove reputation
checkmark 80+ years’ experience
Mayzlin Relocation
checkmark Family owned
checkmark East coast focus
checkmark Affordable pricing
North American Van Lines
checkmark 1,800 trucks
checkmark Storage available
checkmark Customized moving plans

Estimated cost to move from New York City to Indianapolis

These cost ranges are approximate estimates based on a 707-mile move from New York City to Indianapolis using pricing data compiled by moveBuddha as of Dec 11, 2025. moveBuddha aggregates thousands of verified quotes from movers across the country and refreshes the dataset each month to track seasonal shifts and market changes. Your actual cost can differ based on shipment size, extra services, access or parking issues, fuel prices, and timing. We suggest gathering estimates from several companies to get the most accurate pricing.
Studio Icon

Studio / 1 bedroom

  • Moving Company $1,271 – $3,448
  • Moving Container $967 – $1,738
  • Rental Truck $470 – $976
Two Three Bed Icon

2-3 bedrooms

  • Moving Company $1,827 – $4,520
  • Moving Container $1,319 – $2,408
  • Rental Truck $534 – $1,114
Four Bed Icon

4+ bedrooms

  • Moving Company $3,209 – $6,859
  • Moving Container $1,766 – $3,259
  • Rental Truck $702 – $1,377
Recent Moving Price Estimates
The following are real, anonymized quotes requested by moveBuddha readers in the past 48 hours. Prices change with dates and availability; use these as a ballpark, not a guarantee.
Budget Truck Rental
North New Hyde Park, NY Edinburgh, IN
4 Bedrooms
Nov 23, 2025
Mayflower Transit
East Hills, NY Fortville, IN
4 Bedrooms
Nov 23, 2025
Roadway Moving
Old Brookville, NY Wynnedale, IN
1 Bedroom (small)
Nov 12, 2025
Allied Van Lines
Russell Gardens, NY Trafalgar, IN
4 Bedrooms
Nov 03, 2025
Mayzlin Relocation
Great Neck Estates, NY Westfield, IN
1 Bedroom (small)
Oct 28, 2025
North American Van Lines
Bronx, NY Shirley, IN
4 Bedrooms
Oct 15, 2025
Safeway Moving
Island Park, NY Antioch, IN
1 Bedroom (large)
Oct 14, 2025
Colonial Van Lines
New City, NY Paragon, IN
5+ Bedrooms
Sep 23, 2025
1-800-Pack-Rat
Chestnut Ridge, NY Greenwood, IN
Studio apartment
Sep 15, 2025
PODS
Hillburn, NY Indianapolis, IN
4 Bedrooms
Sep 03, 2025

Moving the opposite route? We got you covered with our moving from Indianapolis, IN to New York City, NY guide.

Top local movers for New York City to Indianapolis moves

Searching for a dependable local mover in New York City that also provides long-distance services to Indianapolis can feel overwhelming. That’s where we come in — we’ve analyzed 165 local movers in New York City who specialize in long-distance relocations, factoring in cost, services, and customer feedback.

These are the best local moving companies for getting from New York City to Indianapolis.

  1. Seka Moving: 4.66 out of 5 stars
  2. Piece of Cake Moving & Storage: 4.66 out of 5 stars
  3. NYC Great Movers: 4.64 out of 5 stars
  4. Dumbo Moving and Storage: 4.62 out of 5 stars
  5. Gentle Giant Moving Company: 4.62 out of 5 stars
https://www.facebook.com/BellhopMoving/, https://twitter.com/BellhopMoving
84.8% of all reviews were positive
13.1% of reviews were negative
Read Reviews
Review Analysis
Seka Moving earns top marks from customers who praise efficient service, careful handling of belongings, professional and polite staff, speed, and clear communication. In 495 reviews, 85% are positive, suggesting that most find the company reliable and courteous. Feedback consistently highlights movers’ attention to protecting property and working swiftly, even with challenging jobs or tight schedules. Customers appreciate that estimates and pricing tend to be accurate. Negative input accounts for 13%, where the main complaints center on damaged items, delayed arrival or delivery, and unexpected charges after the move. These issues can be especially frustrating during long-distance relocations, where delivery windows or extra fees sometimes catch people off guard. Neutral reviews typically note reasonable moves but cite problems like slow packing or unclear fee explanations. Compared to many movers, Seka stands out for its organization, efficiency, and respectful treatment of customers’ property, but like others in this industry, a few operational or scheduling missteps sometimes occur. The company’s strength lies in its fast, attentive, and careful crews, making it a leading choice among moving services, especially for local moves.
Get a Quote (212) 203-0280

Company Info

State license #: 40118

Years in Business: 7

DOT #: 3014539

Alternate Names: Seka Moving Corporation

Services Offered

  • Local moves
  • Interstate moves
  • Packing
  • Unpacking
  • Offices
  • Pianos
  • Hot Tubs
  • Pool Tables
  • Art
  • Antiques
  • Grandfather clocks
  • Crating
  • Full-valuation coverage
  • Storage
  • Fragile-only packing
  • Pay by money order
  • Pay by cash
  • Pay by credit card
  • Deposit Required
https://www.facebook.com/BellhopMoving/, https://twitter.com/BellhopMoving
94.5% of all reviews were positive
5.0% of reviews were negative
Read Reviews
Review Analysis
Piece of Cake Moving & Storage makes relocating feel like a breeze for most customers, with 94.5% of nearly 9,000 reviews giving positive feedback. Their crews often win praise for being efficient, friendly, and showing care with belongings, making moves run quickly and protecting furniture well. Many also mention good communication and stress-free experiences, even for moves under tough conditions. Some reviewers highlight organized packing and transparent pricing as standout qualities that set Piece of Cake above their competition in major cities. Still, a small but notable group (5%) describe frustrating experiences such as item damage, surprise charges not made clear upfront, or missing boxes—and a handful share stories of items lost or mishandled during long-distance moves. A few neutral reviews point out that while customer support is responsive, the packing service can fall short of expectations. Compared to similar companies, Piece of Cake is recognized for consistent service, but it’s important for customers to ensure item lists are accurate and to monitor the moving process. For those seeking a smooth, hands-off move with careful, reliable movers, Piece of Cake comes highly recommended, but vigilance is wise to prevent issues common in the industry.
Get a Quote (212) 651-7273

Company Info

State license #: 40244

Years in Business: 6

DOT #: 3066988

Alternate Names: Piece of Cake Moving & Storage LLC

Services Offered

  • Local moves
  • Interstate moves
  • Packing
  • Unpacking
  • Offices
  • Pianos
  • Art
  • Antiques
  • Crating
  • Storage
  • Fragile-only packing
  • Pay by credit card
  • Deposit Required
https://www.facebook.com/BellhopMoving/, https://twitter.com/BellhopMoving
95.0% of all reviews were positive
5.0% of reviews were negative
Read Reviews
Review Analysis
Customer satisfaction runs high for NYC Great Movers, with 95% of the 221 feedback entries praising fast, efficient service and diligent care for belongings. Customers frequently note the team’s professionalism, clear communication, and careful handling during moves. Efficient service and affordability rank as distinguishing features, with many saying the process felt streamlined and organized. While most clients encountered smooth, stress-free moves, some negative input describes incidents with property damage, disputes about unexpected or added charges, and slow or absent follow-up from management when issues occurred. Compared to competitors, NYC Great Movers earns strong marks for reliability and value, but those seeking high-limit insurance coverage or ironclad pricing transparency may want to review policies closely before booking. The overwhelming input leans positive, highlighting the company as a trusted choice for quick, professional moving experiences in New York and beyond.
Get a Quote (718) 285-8565

Company Info

State license #: 39493

Years in Business: 13

DOT #: 2180117

Services Offered

  • Local moves
  • Interstate moves
  • Packing
  • Unpacking
  • Offices
  • Pianos
  • Art
  • Shipment tracking
  • Full-valuation coverage
  • Storage
  • Fragile-only packing
  • Pay by cash
  • Pay by credit card
https://www.facebook.com/BellhopMoving/, https://twitter.com/BellhopMoving
54.9% of all reviews were positive
42.1% of reviews were negative
Read Reviews
Review Analysis
Customers call Dumbo Moving a go-to for affordable, fast, and careful moves. Over 2,100 feedback entries show more than half of the input is positive and under 43% negative. Clients praise the team’s efficient service, attention to detail, courteous crew, fair quotes, and how quickly they finish both local and long-distance jobs. Many appreciate their careful handling of everything from fragile furniture to electronics. Several people highlight reliable performance compared to pricier competitors, with many repeat customers saying they always get what they expect. On the downside, hundreds report cost problems—unexpected charges, extra fees for minor add-ons, and surprise upcharges once belongings are in the truck. A significant portion warn of property damage left unresolved or poorly compensated, and complaints about staff that come off as unhelpful or pushy are common. While speedy moves and competitive rates stand out, the risk of extra charges and inconsistent customer care means Dumbo moves faster than some firms but often delivers a less predictable experience. Fewer companies inspire such loyalty—or frustration—in a crowded industry.
Get a Quote (718) 222-8282

Company Info

State license #: 36990

Years in Business: 18

DOT #: 1543241

Services Offered

  • Local moves
  • Interstate moves
  • International moves
  • Packing
  • Unpacking
  • Offices
  • Pianos
  • Hot Tubs
  • Pool Tables
  • Art
  • Antiques
  • Full-valuation coverage
  • Storage
  • Fragile-only packing
  • Safes
  • Pay by credit card
  • Deposit Required
https://www.facebook.com/BellhopMoving/, https://twitter.com/BellhopMoving
96.1% of all reviews were positive
3.9% of reviews were negative
Read Reviews
Review Analysis
Customer feedback for Gentle Giant Moving Company stands out thanks to an unusually high satisfaction rate: 128 reviews analyzed, with 96% reporting a positive experience. Most clients highlight respectful, professional crews who work efficiently, handle belongings with care, and maintain excellent communication throughout the move. Many mention that moves—whether simple or complex—are quick and problem-free, with polite staff consistently exceeding expectations even in challenging circumstances. On the downside, a small number of clients express frustration over higher-than-expected costs, unexpected charges, and communication delays, especially for long-distance moves. Rare negatives cite slow follow-up or items arriving late. Damage to items is scarcely mentioned compared to competitors, making Gentle Giant’s reputation for careful handling particularly notable. Overall, Gentle Giant earns more praise for reliability, professionalism, and care than most moving companies, with very few clients dissatisfied.
Get a Quote (718) 907-1830

Company Info

State license #: 36518

Years in Business: 43

DOT #: 373544

Alternate Names: Gentle Giant Moving & Storage

Services Offered

  • Local moves
  • Interstate moves
  • International moves
  • Packing
  • Unpacking
  • Offices
  • Pianos
  • Crane vans
  • Storage
  • Pay by credit card

How much does it cost to move from New York City to Indianapolis?

Movers in New York generally charge an average of per hour. Check out these typical costs for a full-service moving company, moving container, or truck rental:

Move size Moving company Moving container Rental
truck
Studio / 1 bedroom $994 – $3,098 $676 – $1,722 $500 – $901
2 – 3 bedrooms $1,827 – $4,520 $1,319 – $2,408 $534 – $1,114
4+ bedrooms $3,209 – $6,859 $1,766 – $3,259 $702 – $1,377
*These price ranges are rough estimates for a 707-mile move from New York City to Indianapolis, based on pricing data compiled by moveBuddha as of Dec 11, 2025. moveBuddha gathers thousands of verified price points from movers nationwide and refreshes the dataset monthly to reflect seasonal shifts and market trends. Your final cost can change with factors like move size, add-on services, parking or access constraints, fuel rates, and timing. We recommend comparing quotes from multiple movers to get the most accurate pricing.

Cost to hire movers from New York City to Indianapolis

Moving a studio or one-bedroom home from New York City to Indianapolis typically costs between $994 and $3,098. For a two- or three-bedroom home, expect prices to fall between $1,827 and $4,520 when moving from New York City to Indianapolis. If you’re tackling a large move (think four or five bedrooms) from New York City to Indianapolis, you’re looking at costs ranging from $3,209 up to $6,859.

Cost of moving containers from New York City to Indianapolis

If you’re relocating from New York City to Indianapolis, you’ll typically spend between $676 and $1,722 for a small move. Have a two or three-bedroom home? Plan for costs to range from $1,319 up to $2,408. If you’re moving a larger home — four bedrooms or more — expect to pay anywhere between $1,766 and $3,259. For a full breakdown, check out our complete PODS cost guide.

Explore our top budget-friendly moving container companies for your move from New York.

Cost of moving truck rentals from New York City to Indianapolis

Renting a moving truck is typically the most budget-friendly choice for a New York City to Indianapolis move, but remember, you’ll be responsible for all the heavy lifting, packing, and driving on your own.

If you’re moving from a studio or one-bedroom place with a rental truck, expect to pay between $500 and $901. For a two- or three-bedroom move, costs usually range from $534 to $1,114. If you’re tackling a four-bedroom or bigger move, your rental truck will likely run between $702 and $1,377.

Estimated fuel costs are already factored into these quotes.

Major factors affecting moving costs from New York City to Indianapolis

The cost of New York City movers will depend on:

  • Move size: The cost of your move depends on how much you’re bringing. A one-bedroom from New York City to Indianapolis might be as low as $1,640, while a four-bedroom could reach $5,478.
  • When you move: Moving in summer often costs more, since it’s the busiest season for movers in New York City.
  • DIY moves vs. full-service help: Truck rentals cost less — around $500 to $1,201 — but you’ll handle all the labor vs. letting professionals do it.

What to know before moving from New York City to Indianapolis

Many movers find Indianapolis easier on the wallet than New York City – roughly 51% less for singles and 56% less for families.

Monthly basics average $2,804 for one person in Indianapolis versus $5,683 in New York City. For a family of four, it’s $6,667 compared with $15,081.

See the cost breakdown below to pinpoint where the savings add up:

New York City Indianapolis
Average 1 BR rent $3,992 $1,688
Average 3 BR rent $8,817 $2,708
Average home value $752,778 $220,467
Average income (per capita) $78,058 $59,110
Cost of living (single) $5,683 $2,804
Cost of living (family of four) $15,081 $6,667
Unemployment rate 11.2% 5.6%
Sales tax 8.0% 7.0%
State income tax 10.9% 3.15%
  • Good news! When moving to Indianapolis from New York City, you’ll benefit from rent being an estimated 68% less, allowing for a more relaxed budget.
  • With home prices being nearly 71% cheaper in Indianapolis, your mortgage budget will remain the same without any significant changes.
  • Be sure to look over your budget before making the move. The average income is about 24% lower in Indianapolis than in New York City.
  • Prepare to enjoy reduced routine costs such as groceries, fuel, and utilities in Indianapolis. The cost of living for a single person is 51% less compared to New York City.
  • Relocating to Indianapolis could provide savings on routine expenses for your family, including transportation, utilities, and groceries. The cost of living for a family is 56% lower than in New York City.
  • With an unemployment rate approximately 50% lower than New York City, Indianapolis boasts a favorable employment scene and thriving economic conditions, ideal for new arrivals.
  • Sales taxes are 13% lower in Indianapolis than New York City, a factor that could decrease expenditure on taxable items if your consumption is higher.
  • Income taxes are 71% lower in Indiana than in New York. Lower income tax rates mean less money is withheld from your paycheck, giving you more flexibility to save, invest, or cover everyday expenses.

Take a detailed look at how everyday expenses stack up between New York City and Indianapolis, from monthly bills to routine purchases:

Living Expense New York City Indianapolis
Basic utilities $186.67 $231.67
Cell phone plan $57.90 $62.58
Dozen eggs $6.33 $3.33
Loaf of bread $5.04 $3.00
Fast-food/casual eatery (one meal) $28.00 $25.00
Dinner for 2 (mid-range restaurant) $135.00 $60.00
Gym membership $159.00 $35.50
  • Basic utilities cost less in New York City than in Indianapolis, helping trim your monthly bills.
  • Cell phone plans are cheaper in New York City than in Indianapolis.
  • Eggs cost more in New York City than in Indianapolis.
  • Bread is more expensive in New York City than in Indianapolis.
  • A quick meal tends to cost more in New York City than in Indianapolis.
  • A mid-range dinner for two is pricier in New York City than in Indianapolis.
  • Gym memberships cost more in New York City than in Indianapolis.

How life is different in New York City vs. Indianapolis

New York City Indianapolis
Population 8,258,035 887,642
Transportation score 10 5
Walkability score 88 31
Bike friendliness score 69 43
Crime index 50.83 60.71
Safety index 49.17 39.29
Air quality Good Good
  • Indianapolis’s population is about 89% less than New York City.
  • Indianapolis’s public transportation score of 5 out of 10 is lower than New York City’s score of 10.
  • Indianapolis is less walkable than New York City with a score of 31 out of 100 vs New York City’s 88 out of 100.
  • Indianapolis has a bike-friendliness score of 43 out of 100, which means it isn’t as accessible or safe for cyclists as New York City, which has a score of 69.
  • Indianapolis’s crime rate is higher than New York City with a score of 60.71 compared to New York City’s 50.83. This means that Indianapolis neighborhoods are safer than 60.71% of all U.S. neighborhoods, and New York City neighborhoods are safer than 50.83%.
  • Indianapolis is considered to be less safe than New York City with a score of 39.29 vs New York City’s 49.17.
  • Air quality in Indianapolis is Good, and in New York City it’s Good.

Other things to consider for your New York City to Indianapolis move

  • HOA rules: To keep things running smoothly, make sure you’re familiar with any HOA or community moving policies before the big day.
  • Elevator reservation: If there is an elevator in your building, it’s a good idea to secure a reservation before your moving day.
  • Truck parking permits: Research parking requirements in your destination city to ensure your truck won’t run into restrictions.
  • State licensing: The Indiana Department of Transportation (INDOT) regulate movers operating within Indiana and issue moving companies Indiana Households Goods Carriers Numbers. Check to make sure prospective movers have one and that it’s up to date. Make sure the moving company you use has a license before hiring.
  • State regulator: You can check the status of a Indiana moving license through the state’s public utilities commission.
  • Moving Permits: You won’t need a moving permit in Indiana, though it’s smart to double-check any local parking restrictions ahead of your move.
  • Change of address: We recommend submitting your USPS change of address form at least one week before your move to ensure your mail gets forwarded to Indianapolis without delay. You can select your official move date when completing the form. Start the process here.
  • Moving company insurance: State laws differ on mover insurance. Opt for Released Value Protection – a budget-friendly choice with no extra cost from movers, though coverage is limited to 60 cents per pound. For instance, if a 50-inch TV weighing 25 pounds is lost or damaged, reimbursement is just $15. To ensure coverage for your items’ full value, discuss alternative options with your chosen moving company or consider third-party insurance providers.
  • Moving checklist: Our moving checklist will help you have the peace of mind that you’ve got everything covered.

Where to live in Indianapolis

Ready to relocate to Amateur Sports Capital of the World? Here are some of the top neighborhoods to consider in Indianapolis.

Best neighborhoods for singles

  • Broad Ripple Village
  • Fountain Square
  • Mile Square
  • Meridian-Kessler
  • Old Northside

Best neighborhoods for families

  • Avon
  • Brownsburg
  • Carmel
  • Fishers
  • Westfield

Things to do in Indianapolis

Now that you’ve made the move to Indiana, it’s the perfect time to explore Indianapolis. From local hotspots to hidden gems, there’s something to enjoy for every lifestyle:

  • Arts and culture: Cultural attractions in Indianapolis include museums and art centers like the Children’s Museum of Indianapolis, Indianapolis Motor Speedway Museum, Indianapolis Museum of Art, and The Eiteljorg Museum.
  • Outdoor recreation: Outdoor lovers will appreciate Eagle Creek Park, White River State Park, Broad Ripple Park, and Krannert Park, along with many other spots perfect for walking, cycling, and fresh air adventures.
  • Sports: Catch a live game and cheer on the home team at an Indianapolis Colts (NFL)Indianapolis Pacers (NBA)Indianapolis Fever (WNBA) game.

FAQ

When is the best time to move from New York City to Indianapolis?

Spring and fall are the ideal times to move from New York City to Indianapolis. You’ll benefit from more comfortable weather and avoid the higher prices that come with peak moving season in New York City.

When is the cheapest time to move from New York City to Indianapolis?

With many people choosing to move from New York City to Indianapolis in spring or fall, winter moves often come with better rates. Take a look at our moving discounts guide to find out how to save.

How long does a move from New York City to Indianapolis take?

Covering 707 miles, the move from New York City, NY to Indianapolis, typically takes one to six days. Some New York City movers may offer faster options, and if your timing is flexible, storage services in Indianapolis can help bridge the gap.

Do movers in New York City offer any discounts?

Many do — and the types of discounts available can help you cut costs. 3 movers in New York City offer AAA member savings. 8 movers provide military discounts. 9 movers extend senior citizen discounts.

Because offers change, confirm details with your mover to make sure you’re getting the most out of available deals.

How many movers in New York City can handle specialty items for my move to Indianapolis?

Specialty moving services aren’t offered by every company. In New York City, 146 movers can handle pianos. 117 offer antique moving services. Compared to the rest of NY, there are 115 piano movers and 82 antique movers, while nationwide the numbers are 2,300 and 1,465 respectively.

If you need these services, it’s best to book early — availability can be limited, especially during peak moving months.

Helpful moving resources

Not what you were looking for?

Check out other categories that can help you find the information you need!

See All
Hide All
triangle triangle