Best Movers Near Sheffield, IL (2025 Guide)

Ryan Carrigan

Last Updated: Nov 4, 2025 • 5 min read

Fact Checked by: Hilary Snow

Out of 100 moving companies reviewed in Illinois, TWO MEN AND A TRUCK came out ahead as the leading choice for local moves in Sheffield, IL. With 237 total reviews and a 83.5% positive rating, they’re a standout among the competition.

For cross-country or out-of-state moves, Safeway Moving delivers on both quality and cost-effectiveness.

Hi, I'm Ryan.
Let's get moving.

I've helped thousands of people move over the last decade, and I can tell you that no two moves are exactly alike. Let me help you find the mover that's right for you.

Best local IL mover:

TWO MEN AND A TRUCK

4.58
Best interstate mover:

Safeway Moving

4.85
Best DIY moving option:

U-Haul Truck Rental

4.15

Need more help? Build your move plan.

Get Quote

Preferred partners

Company	Quote	Rating
Safeway Moving	Get A Quote	4.85 / 5
International Van Lines	Get A Quote	4.45 / 5
Mayzlin Relocation	Get A Quote	4.9 / 5

Our track record

Each year, 400,000+ people trust our moving recommendations. Here are a few reasons why:

Founded in 2015
3,500+ moving companies analyzed
$50,000 in moving grants delivered
Up-to-date pricing info & industry data
Fact-checked for accuracy

5 Cheapest movers when moving locally in Sheffield, IL

Whether you're planning a move within Sheffield or relocating to a nearby Illinois city like Buda or Neponset (both under 50 miles away), we’ve rounded up some of the best local movers that combine solid reputations with affordable pricing.

TWO MEN AND A TRUCK: 4.58 out of 5 stars
Mordue Moving and Storage: 4.5 out of 5 stars
Horizon Movers & Climate Control Storage: 4.3 out of 5 stars
O'Mara Moving & Storage Inc.: 4.38 out of 5 stars
Riley Moving And Storage: 4.06 out of 5 stars

TWO MEN AND A TRUCK

1030 W Olympia Dr, Peoria, IL 61615 US

84% of all reviews were positive

14% of reviews were negative

Read Reviews

Review Analysis

Moving made smoother—most customer input about TWO MEN AND A TRUCK highlights fast, polite, and careful service. We analyzed 237 pieces of feedback and found 84% were positive. Common praise mentions courteous, hardworking staff and efficient, organized moves that safeguard belongings. People often note how movers wrap furniture well, help with packing, and act professionally, making the process less stressful. Many felt comfortable recommending the service or returning for future moves, saying the company stands out for friendliness and attention to detail compared to typical moving firms. Some experienced delayed resolutions for damaged items, and a few flagged worries with complaint handling or surprise charges. Property damage and lack of follow-up after incidents remain the biggest areas for improvement, leaving some customers dissatisfied. On balance, input shows TWO MEN AND A TRUCK delivers skillful moves and high standards of care, well above what’s usual in the industry, though customers appreciate clearer communication if an issue occurs.

Get a Quote (309) 455-4036

Company Info

State license #: 1566

Years in Business: 21

DOT #: 2527384

Services Offered

Local moves
Interstate moves
Packing
Unpacking
Pianos
Storage
Safes
Pay by credit card

Mordue Moving and Storage

9011 N University St, Peoria, IL 61615 US

76% of all reviews were positive

21% of reviews were negative

Read Reviews

Review Analysis

Customers rave about Mordue Moving and Storage's polite, professional approach and careful handling of belongings. Three out of four reviewers shared great feedback, noting quick, efficient moves and clear communication throughout. Many praise the movers' reliability, attention to detail, and their ability to handle challenging or delicate items. Staff frequently receive compliments for being friendly and willing to go the extra mile. Some customers did report serious problems: the most significant concerns relate to property damage during moves, unexpected charges beyond estimates, and instances where items were lost or left behind. A few noted lapses in responsiveness from the company after issues occurred. Despite these problems, Mordue receives more enthusiastic praise compared to many moving companies. Most customers express high satisfaction and are comfortable recommending their service to others.

Get a Quote (800) 359-3011

Company Info

State license #: 10316

Years in Business: 89

DOT #: 70719

Alternate Names: Paul Arpin Van Lines

Services Offered

Local moves
Interstate moves
International moves
Packing
Unpacking
Offices
Pianos
Pool Tables
Art
Antiques
Full-valuation coverage
Storage
Fragile-only packing
Safes
Pay by credit card

Horizon Movers & Climate Control Storage

4726 N Brady St, Davenport, IA 52806 US

98% of all reviews were positive

1% of reviews were negative

Read Reviews

Review Analysis

Movers making moving easy—feedback for Horizon Movers & Climate Control Storage stands out among local moving companies. 232 reviews were analyzed, with 98% reporting positive experiences. Customers often highlight their careful handling of belongings, professional and polite teams, efficiency, fast process, and clear communication. Many mention respectful treatment of property and stress-free relocations, including for long-distance and complicated moves. A few reports note unprofessional scheduling behavior, some items being damaged, or poor communication, though these are rare. Compared to other movers, Horizon receives more praise for reliability, attention to detail, and courteous service, cementing its reputation as a top choice for hassle-free and trustworthy moving and storage services.

Get a Quote (563) 381-9866

Company Info

Years in Business: 27

DOT #: 763103

Alternate Names: Megladon Inc

Services Offered

Local moves
Interstate moves
International moves
Packing
Unpacking
Offices
Pianos
Hot Tubs
Pool Tables
Art
Antiques
Crating
Full-valuation coverage
Storage
Pay by cash
Pay by credit card

O'Mara Moving & Storage Inc.

1240 S Adams Ave, Freeport, IL 61032 US

74% of all reviews were positive

23% of reviews were negative

Read Reviews

Review Analysis

Moving with O'Mara means many customers get prompt, courteous service from professional and communicative staff who handle belongings with care. Out of 31 pieces of feedback studied, nearly three-quarters praised polite crews, careful handling, smooth coordination, affordable rates, and clear recommendations. Those with positive experiences frequently note how staff minimized costs, managed timing efficiently, and made the transition stress-free. On the other hand, some users reported problems such as damaged furniture, unreturned calls, unreliable arrival times, and disrespectful behavior. While most clients enjoyed dependable communication and respect for property, a small group experienced major setbacks with broken items and disappointing customer service. Compared to other movers, O'Mara stands out for reasonable pricing and professionalism but has received a few consistent complaints around accountability and handling in rare cases.

Get a Quote (815) 232-2512

Company Info

State license #: 5095

Years in Business: 159

DOT #: 144182

Services Offered

Local moves
Interstate moves
International moves
Packing
Unpacking
Offices
Pianos
Art
Antiques
Grandfather clocks
Crating
Shipment tracking
Full-valuation coverage
Storage
Fragile-only packing
Pay by cash
Pay by credit card

Riley Moving And Storage

7312 Hancock Ct, Davenport, IA 52806 US

81% of all reviews were positive

16% of reviews were negative

Read Reviews

Review Analysis

Customers frequently describe Riley Moving And Storage as professional, careful, and responsive. In an analysis of 31 reviews, about 81% provided positive feedback, praising the team's attentive communication, tidy handling of furniture, efficient service, and competitive rates. Clients noted staff were courteous, belongings arrived undamaged, and movers kept in touch during the entire process—benefits often not found with moving companies. A few customers mentioned affordable pricing, which sets them apart in the industry. Some negative reviewers pointed to broken or damaged items, with one highlighting a lack of care and problematic claims process, and a few mentioning rushed jobs or careless packing. Neutral feedback pointed to occasional inconsistency in packing techniques but still credited the teams for careful handling. While the vast majority recommend Riley for hassle-free moves, those with less favorable experiences expressed frustration over damaged goods and how issues were resolved.

Get a Quote (563) 391-1940

Company Info

Services Offered

Local moves
Interstate moves
International moves
Packing
Unpacking
Offices
Art
Antiques
Crating
Full-valuation coverage
Storage
Fragile-only packing
Pay by money order
Pay by cash
Pay by credit card

Local moving services in Sheffield

Not all moving companies offer the same services, and availability can vary widely depending on where you're located.

Here’s a quick look at how many movers in Sheffield, IL, offer key services, compared with the statewide and national numbers so you can see which specialty services may be harder to find in your area.

Service	Sheffield	IL	National
Packing	1	95	3069
Unpacking	1	91	2969
Piano	1	70	2299
Antiques	1	48	1465
Art	1	50	1449
Storage	1	89	2692
Climate-Controlled Storage	1	34	1030
Fragile-Only Packing	1	30	747
Office Moves	1	82	2705
Pool Table	1	28	969
Safe	1	42	1155

Other local IL movers

While these local Illinois movers did not make our top list, they are still worth looking into:

Top-rated movers in other nearby Illinois cities

Explore additional highly rated moving companies across IL to find the services you need, even if they’re not offered in your immediate area.

See less

Cheapest movers when moving out of Illinois

If you're relocating from Illinois to a new state, choosing a trusted interstate moving company is key to making the transition smooth. Here are a few of our top picks to get you started:

Safeway Moving: 4.85 out of 5 stars
International Van Lines: 4.45 out of 5 stars
Mayzlin Relocation: 4.9 out of 5 stars
PODS: 4.8 out of 5 stars
American Van Lines: 4.5 out of 5 stars

Safeway Moving

rating

4.85 / 5

Licensed

Insured

Price

Best overall value
Portion to charity
Veteran owned

Get A Quote

(855) 650-0657

International Van Lines

rating

4.45 / 5

Licensed

Insured

Price

24/7 cust. service
Competitive rates
10% discounts

Get A Quote

(855) 929-4120

Mayzlin Relocation

rating

4.9 / 5

Licensed

Insured

Price

Family owned
East coast focus
Affordable pricing

Get A Quote

(980) 217-6841

PODS

rating

4.8 / 5

Licensed

Insured

Price

Unlimited storage
3 container sizes
10% discount

Get A Quote

Visit Website

American Van Lines

rating

4.5 / 5

Licensed

Insured

Price

Certified crews
Flat-rate pricing
Family-owned

Get A Quote

866-835-2392

Cheapest DIY moving options in Sheffield, IL

Hiring a full-service mover in Sheffield, Illinois offers maximum convenience, but it’s also the most expensive option. If you’d like to save, consider one of the best moving container companies or opt for a truck rental company instead.

PODS

rating

4.8 / 5

Licensed

Insured

Price

Unlimited storage
3 container sizes
10% discount

Get A Quote

Visit Website

U-Pack

rating

5 / 5

Licensed

Insured

Price

Fast delivery
Nationwide
100+ miles moves

Check prices Visit Website

MovingYourself

rating

4.5 / 5

Licensed

Insured

Price

Affordable pricing
Offers car shipping
No hidden fees

Get A Quote

(352) 322-2920

Budget Truck Rental

rating

4.3 / 5

Licensed

Insured

Price

Affordable pricing
Online pricing
Several discounts

Check prices Visit Website

How we chose the best movers in Sheffield, IL

moveBuddha’s expert team analyzed moving rates from 82 Illinois movers and listed the top five best movers based on customer satisfaction, reviews, and cost.

Customer satisfaction (40%): The company consistently delivers services in a timely matter with good communication and within the estimated cost.

Dispute resolution (20%): Mistakes cannot be avoided in the moving industry. We look for companies that own their mistakes and make genuine efforts to fix any issues that arise during a move.

Industry reputation (15%): The company is well-regarded within the moving industry and participates in industry conferences and organizations.

Online reputation (15%): The company maintains a professional website with accurate information. The company promptly and professionally responds to online customer inquiries.

Service options (10%): We look for companies with a deep breadth of services including full packing, storage, specialty item handling, and expedited delivery.

Here is our full moving company rating methodology.

Average cost of movers in Sheffield, IL

Use the pricing table below to get a general sense of what local moving costs look like in and around Sheffield. If you want more in-depth info, check out our full guide on moving costs in Illinois.

Keep in mind that the moving quotes provided are just rough estimates. Your actual cost will depend on the specifics of your move. For a more accurate estimate, use our moving cost calculator.

Home Size	Avg. Total Cost	Cost/hour	# of Movers	# Hours
Studio	$404	$133	2 movers	3 hours
1 Bedroom	$537	$133	2 movers	4 hours
2 Bedroom	$830	$186	3 movers	5 hours
3 Bedroom	$1,833	$260	4 movers	8 hours
4 Bedroom	$2,093	$260	4 movers	9 hours
5+ Bedroom	$3,189	$365	5 movers	10 hours

Compare the top Sheffield, IL movers

Let’s compare how the top movers in Sheffield, IL stack up in terms of their reputation.

Company	moveBuddha rating	BBB rating	Yelp rating	Google rating
TWO MEN AND A TRUCK	4.6/5	A+	3/5	4.5/5
Mordue Moving and Storage	4.5/5	A+	2.5/5	4.3/5
Horizon Movers & Climate Control Storage	4.3/5	A+	4.6/5	4.9/5
O'Mara Moving & Storage Inc.	4.4/5	A+		4.4/5
Riley Moving And Storage	4.1/5		2.3/5	4.5/5
Bloomington Relocation Systems	4.3/5	NR	5/5	4.3/5
Maher Bros. Transfer and Storage	4/5		2.3/5	4.3/5
Bellhop Moving	4.4/5	C	3.6/5	4.4/5

FAQs

How many movers in Sheffield offer discounts?

Some moving companies in Sheffield offer discounts tailored to certain customers. If you're eligible, these offers can lower your total cost without reducing service quality.

AAA discounts are available from 1 companies. 1 movers support military families with reduced rates. 1 offer discounted pricing to seniors in the area. Always check directly with each mover to confirm the details and any fine print.

How can I verify if my mover is legally licensed?

In Illinois, regulations on in-state moves and local movers are set forth by the Illinois Commerce Commission. To move household goods locally and intrastate, companies need to have a Certificate of Public Convenience and Necessity, so make sure the companies you’re considering have one and that it’s current.

Every mover featured in our guide is fully licensed. Check out our best movers in Illinois page for top picks.

What should I look for in a reputable Sheffield mover?

Choosing a reputable Sheffield moving company doesn’t have to be hard if you focus on a few key considerations:

Reputation: Whether it's a family-run business or a major van lines provider, their reputation tells you a lot about what to expect.
Dispute resolution: Companies with many unresolved issues are red flags. Even top Sheffield movers have occasional hiccups— it’s how they handle them that matters.
Move-specific experience: Just because a mover is great for local jobs doesn't mean they’re ready for your long-distance move. Ask about their experience with moves like yours.

When is the most affordable day to hire movers in Sheffield, IL?

Movers in Sheffield, Illinois, are usually cheapest on weekdays, as weekends tend to be busier and more expensive. Typically, the most affordable time to move falls between October and April. Moving costs spike between May and September due to high demand during peak season.

It’s best to book your Sheffield move early. To save money, try to avoid weekends, holidays, and peak summer months. And remember, a low initial quote isn’t always a good sign. Some movers increase the price on moving day after low-balling up front.

How can I move out of state from Sheffield, IL on a budget?

If you're looking to save money, renting a moving truck is the most affordable way to move out of state or even locally within Sheffield, Illinois. It’s a DIY solution, though, so you’ll be responsible for packing, loading, unloading, and doing all the driving.

Is using a moving container a smart choice for my move from Sheffield?

Moving containers give you the flexibility to move on your schedule, but you’ll need to handle all the lifting and loading yourself. Once everything is packed, the container company will take care of transporting it to your new home, so you can skip the hassle of driving a moving truck.